Made Here
Weight, What?
Season 20 Episode 12 | 29m 10sVideo has Closed Captions
Weight discrimination and stigma are causing more harm than we thought.
The effects of weight stigma and discrimination are widespread and extremely detrimental to the health and well-being of individuals. Massachusetts has a chance to lead the charge and protect its residents from discrimination based on body size.
Made Here is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by the John M. Bissell Foundation, Inc. | Learn about the Made Here Fund
Made Here
Weight, What?
Season 20 Episode 12 | 29m 10sVideo has Closed Captions
The effects of weight stigma and discrimination are widespread and extremely detrimental to the health and well-being of individuals. Massachusetts has a chance to lead the charge and protect its residents from discrimination based on body size.
How to Watch Made Here
Made Here is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipPart of These Collections
Public Affairs & Social Issues
Encounter diverse perspectives on a range of public affairs topics and contemporary issues
View CollectionProviding Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship-Hi.
I'm -Eric Ford for made here.
-Wait, what?
-From Boston based -filmmaker Sarah Fury -examines -the effects of weight -stigma and discrimination -in Massachusetts.
-The film profiles -the efforts in the state -to change legislation -protecting US residents -from discrimination -based on body size.
-You can watch -Weight, What?
-and other great -made here film -streaming on our website -and through the PBS app.
-Enjoy the film -and thanks for watching.
-To younger me.
-I wish you had the courage -to love your body -when others didn't.
-I wish you realized -there were more -important things -than being a size two, -5 or 10.
-I wish instead of looking -for imperfections, -you noticed your strength.
-I wish you knew -you were beautiful.
-We're going to start -seated.
-Looks like -we're all ready for there.
-Letting the -body just -slowly increase movement.
-Starting from the neck -and head.
-Inhale.
-Exhale.
Inhale -all the way up.
-Nice and tall.
-Hopefully -you feel a few inches -tall or some rough hands.
-Meet palms.
-Now let's take another -few rounds of sun breath -so we can connection -with the ground.
-Pressing down.
-Leaning back using -the slack of the rope.
-If you wanted to bend -the knee and play -with your figure -four on this side.
-I have suffered as others -have suffered -from trying -to fit into boxes.
-So for me, body acceptance -means being honest.
-And my work with yoga -and work with more to love -is really about broadening -what I mean by this sense -of being honest -with yourself.
-So when I think about body -positivity -and body acceptance, -I care more about us -as individuals.
-Learning to feel and sense -in our true bodies -in this moment.
-I'm ray of support -and I'm the creator -of more to love Yoga, -and I'm also -an entrepreneur -that prioritizes health -and well-being -for larger bodies.
-I've always loved -moving my body.
-My favorite thing -is actually to stretch.
-so when I went to a yoga -class for the first time, -I wish I could tell you -it was awesome.
-It was not.
-It was a terrible, -terrible experience.
-The teacher, -while lovely, was not -equipped for a larger body.
-so I kind of hidvv -in the back -like so many other -people's stories, -and then they turned -the heat on, and, like, -you're speaking -this different language, - and I just got overwhelmed.
- I had a panic attack in the -class, and I ran outside.
-Whenever a trade is in me.
-I tried another studio, -and I got into the habit -of practicing in the back, -and I also got into the -habit of closing my eyes -and then the deeper -I got into yoga -and the practice of body -acceptance and attunement, -I started to teach other -people what I was learning.
-and then eventually -I went to yoga school -specifically -for the intention -of bringing yoga -to larger bodies.
-and then now it's been -eight years of practically -every single week.
-There has been a more -to love yoga class.
-Entering -the more to love yoga -space has been -my first true experience in -being in a class -where it's geared towards -a larger body.
-prior to that, -I've just taken classes -at various different gyms.
-and kind of always felt -a little bit out of place.
-I haven't always been -heavier, like, -I used to be really thin -than I was more like -average size -and like -since -putting on more weight, -I have felt really like -self -conscious in dance classes.
-because like most of -the people around me are, -you know, a lot smaller.
-And I saw this and I was -like, this is perfect.
-Like, it's so exciting.
-I've been doing yoga -personally -since I was seven.
-I grew -up in a straight size body.
-I developed -an eating disorder -and healed -into a larger body.
-So this is a newer -experience for me.
-But I haven't done a yoga -class -in maybe over ten years -or so because of that -fear of being with thinner -or straight sized folks.
-And it has been so freeing -to be able -to come to a place -where your size does -not matter and to feel -that joy of a community -and to practice yoga again.
-According to a study -by the centers for Disease -Control and Prevention, -the percentage -of overweight adults -in the United States -has steadily been rising -despite our population -getting bigger.
-Our weight bias -is not getting smaller.
-A Harvard study of implicit -and explicit attitudes -over time -looked at attitudes -and disability, age, skin -tone, race, sexuality, -and body weight out of all -six groups.
-Explicit body weight -attitudes -showed the slowest change -toward attitude neutrality, -and implicit -bias on body weight -moved in the opposite -direction, -away from neutrality.
-I have been fat -my entire life.
-Born fat to a fat family.
-so it -has been something that I, -quote unquote, struggle -with my whole life.
-I think the biggest -frustration really, -for me is that -my size is the first thing -that you see -and the last thing -you remember.
-What you are thinking about -me is what you're going - to put on me forever.
- And I can't shake it.
- I can't get rid of it.
- Like my presence -is offensive -to a lot of people.
-Just my existence -brings offense.
-And it's it's so hard -now that I really think -and think about it.
-It's just really hard -to just be -because, like, you know, -you take up space, -but then you don't -want to take up space, -especially in this area -like Boston -where you're on the train, -right?
-And you're like, -and you know, you're taking -the space of two people, -but you don't want to.
-And then people -are looking at you -and then you -don't want to exist.
And -yeah, -people are quick to jump -to assumptions.
-just looking at somebody -in anybody.
-Right?
-We look at them -and we make assumptions and we have biases.
But I think for people, -larger bodies, people jump -to such abrasive -assumptions very quickly.
-But I've also kind of -learned to that -a lot of that comes from -how they feel -about their own body -and how they project -a lot of how they feel.
-Aren't you fear of fatness?
-It's this fear -that like one day -you could end up in a body -that society doesn't like -or you know -your partner doesn't like, -or the people on dating -apps don't like.
-It's just this -almost like disgust.
-Like, don't get it on me.
-Like, don't, don't -get your fatness on me.
-It's taking up -too much space.
-And with that comes -just like -hatred, -disrespect, disgust.
-Like it's all these, like, -really gross feelings and -really gross actions toward -fat people -in a 2006 study -of over 20,000 people -in larger bodies, -around 70% -said they have experienced -other people -making negative assumptions -about them.
-Other -stigmatizing situations -include negative comments -by children, -doctors, family and others.
-Fat people experience -a lack of options -or choices with how to show -up in the world, -whether that's -losing weight and -assimilating to society.
-What society -wants for them, or act out -by remaining fat, -wants for them, or act out -by remaining fat, -and especially being fat -and happy like, -oh, never be fat and happy.
-but as we go up the scale -of like small fat, mid fat, -large fat, super -fat and fat, that's fat, -like the fatter -you are, the harder -it is to assimilate, -the harder -it is to like -get along with your thin, -straight size companions -and not be against -the rules.
-Weight -stigma is everywhere.
-It is woven into the fabric -of our society.
-Whether it is over -and someone is literally, -you know, unfortunately, -maybe talking about someone -in a larger body -talking about themselves, -the message -that is being told -is that -being thin is superior -and there's -something wrong.
-If you are not fitting -some type of smaller body -ideal, -and I won't treat you -the same if you are not, -and you don't get -the same answers from me -if you are not, and that -should be your priority.
-If you are not, and it is -your fault if you are not.
-and that is the narrative -that is is pushed -and has been told -and sold to us.
-The evidence is clear -that weight stigma -and discrimination -impact on people's -lives in myriad ways.
-Their health for sure.
-ability to access -confident health care.
-but also there are -opportunities in schools, -in the workplace.
-We know that -in the workplace -there is rampant weight -discrimination.
-And it could be people -not being hired, -people being fired, -people being a docked pay -not getting promoted.
-All of these ways -that weight discrimination -is holding people back -and undermining people's -life chances.
-Many studies have shown -that a worker's weight -adversely -impacts their wages.
-In one study, -those in larger bodies -started -with identical wages -as their skinny colleagues, -but 17 years later, -we're making a dollar -and 20 less.
-The obesity wage -penalty is worse for women.
-One study suggests -that for every 6 pounds, -an average American woman -gains her hourly -pay drops 2%.
-The idea that, -somebody should be making -less of a living wage -because -they live in a larger body, -is outrageous to me.
-your body size doesn't -determine your ability to -function in the workplace.
-They'll have been -mistreated -and discriminated -against unfairly -for either a promotion or, -getting a position, -making a living wage -so that they can support -their family -and imagine -adding more stress on -because you cannot make -the amount of money -that you are -entitled to earn based -on your qualifications.
-Just earlier this year, -I was doing -a back of the envelope kind -of calculation -of what percent of the U.S. -population actually lives -in an area with protections - against wage -discrimination.
- And actually, my -my calculation -was pretty sobering.
-It was less than 10% -of the country -actually benefits -from protections against weight -discrimination.
They live in a place where -this has been outlawed.
-What that means -is more than 90% -of the country -lives in a place -where they have absolutely -no protection against -being fired at work, docked -pay, demoted.
-Most people don't realize - they could wake up -tomorrow.
- The boss tells them, -I don't like your weight.
-You're fired.
-And you would -have no way to fight that.
-There's sort of an age -old question of whether -law pushes society -or society pushes law.
-and this is one of those -moments where -there's a much better, -more robust, -more compassionate -and understanding, -appreciation of different -body sizes of health, -at a variety of sizes -and at a lack -of healthiness -at a variety of sizes.
-And I think there's also -a general -understanding that body -shaming at any size -is not a helpful thing, -just period.
-Though senate 1108 -is an act to prohibit -body size discrimination.
-it applies -to both height and weight, -and it literally does -exactly what the title says.
It would prohibit -discrimination -on the basis of body size, -in a variety of contexts, -including education, health -care, employment, -basic government -services, etc.
-bills -can take a very long time -to become a law -if they even do.
-Way back in 2015, -Byron Rushing, -then a Massachusetts state -representative, -petitioned an act -making discrimination -on the basis of height -and weight.
-Unlawful year after year.
-The bill was moving -through the process -and being reviewed -by committees, -but never made its way -to the floor for a vote.
-So I came in in 2019, -along with my friend -and colleague -representative -and the two of us picked up -the bill in our first term.
-And I'm very proud -that in that term, -for the first time ever -in the history -of Massachusetts, -the bill did garner a -favorable committee report.
-However, they still did not -get the bill to the floor -for a vote.
-Two years later, -they had another hearing.
-So on November 23rd, -I virtually spoke -to the Joint committee -in support of this anti -weight discrimination bill.
-And one of the things -that I said in there, -which is true, -is that -when I was diagnosed -with Covid in March 2020, -I put off going to -the hospital for days -because I was afraid -that they were going -to make a big deal -about my weight.
-That is because -of the trauma -that is because of the -lived -and learned experience -going into some settings -on a larger -body, -you're not taken seriously.
-So I made sure to speak -about that experience -to the joint committee -because one, it's -not just happening -to me, it's happening -to so many people.
-And the sense that weight -shame prevents us -from engaging in society.
-Unfortunately, again, -the bill did not -go to the floor for a vote.
-So what's happened -since that hearing is that -the bill was reintroduced.
-So we met with Senator -Rausch and Representative -Quinn a few months ago -and have just been staying -in touch with their offices -since then.
-We always want to be in -touch with the legislators -about the strength -of the bill, -but also to offer -our support in coordinating -the community -around the bill.
-So with only a few days -notice -for the hearing -in Massachusetts, -we sort of teamed up -with bigger bodies.
-Boston, -the local organizing group -that does a lot of social -and, community -support things for larger -bodied folks -to get the word out -on social media -to encourage -people to testify.
-And we put together -some resources -to support people -in testifying.
-and then, of course, -I and my colleague -from Claire both testified -in support of the bill.
-This week, -I am Tigress Osborne, -executive director of Nafa, -the National Association -to Advance Fat Acceptance.
-So 54 years Nafa has fought -for the rights of fat -people with a mission -of changing perceptions -of fat -and ending size -discrimination.
-Earlier this week was a -joint committee meeting.
-It was the House -and the Senate hearing -combined into one.
-There were a total of 13 -testimonies, -including the senator, -and there were only two -in opposition.
-And the testimony -in support of the bill.
-We're really powerful.
-So I feel really good -about it this time around.
-And I think -that Massachusetts -has a real opportunity here -to, you know, -to follow Michigan -in setting an example, -but to be a much -more modern example.
-And so that will have -different -ripple effects as well.
-So what will happen -next is we'll need around -our constituent influence -to let -the speaker of the House -and the Senate chair -know that, like these -are bills we want to see -get on the docket -for a vote.
-You know, -we have people contacting -their own representatives -to say like, -hey, what's up with that -bill Senator -Rausch and Representative -Nolan are doing?
-You signed on to that, -right?
-Are you going to co-sponsor -that right.
-You're going to call -for a vote on that, right?
-It is kind of, -situation of, -sometimes the -squeaky wheel gets the oil.
-And so we -just got to squeak louder -than we've -ever squeaked in the past.
-That's what it is.
-You know, -we just got to get louder -than we've ever been -in the past.
-So I think we're more ready -than we've ever been -at both now, -as an organization -and fat activist, -fat liberation community -as a whole, -I think -just putting this in place, -I don't think it's going -to solve everything, -of course, -but I think it's a step -in the right direction -where we talk -about these things -a little bit more.
-I truly believe that -body love is contagious -just like any other, -you know, social disease -or triumph.
-Humans are wired to connect -and we mimic -and we follow one another.
-So if you want something -different in the world, -you got to do it -on yourself first.
-And it's the self work -that is the most important -for this.
-So learning -how you actually talk -and treat yourself, -your own views, taking time -to maybe question -or challenge things -that you just assumed -or have always carried -with you.
-That is ultimately -the first step -in self-compassion -and can be -a really integral piece -in terms of like -finding a peaceful -relationship with your body -because you're not always -going to feel good -about your body.
-That's just kind of the, -you know, that's real.
-At the end of the day, -you're going to have days -where you're like, yes, -this is me, -and I'm doing well, -and you're going to -have days when you're like, -well, -I just need to exist today.
-and that's okay, -because it is about kind -of being able to be -at peace with yourself -and like also allowing -that attitude -to kind of like -permeate the existence.
-It starts with -just like talking -about experiences -and listening -to other people's -experiences -with anything that I've -been unsure of or judged.
-If I learn more about it, -I'm like, oh wait, may -I see this -in a whole new light?
-And to also -not only -respect our differences, -but to like, celebrate -and embrace them, -I think is an even further -step, right?
-Like the first step -is neutrality.
-The next step would be like -truly embracing -and celebrating it.
-We need to create safe -spaces for folks -in larger bodies -by, you know, -learning and unlearning -some of these things -that we have been taught -throughout our lives.
-We see a lot of things -through the weight -normative lens, -the weight focused lens, -and so really expanding -our reading and expanding -our media consumption, -to things -that are more inclusive, -maybe body accepting, body -positive social media -these days is -is essentially a cesspool -of fat shaming, of weight -stigma, of predatory diet -industry companies -and influencers -trying to make a buck off -of discrimination -and stigma.
-I mean, more and more -comes out every day -about how these companies, -the social media platforms, -keep allowing -these kinds of predatory -influencers and companies -and other kinds of hate -speech really -to proliferate online.
-I highly recommend -that you just start -unfollowing the accounts -that make you feel icky, -especially about your body.
-Are you following -a bunch of influencers -who are like drinking flat -tummy tea, or is there -a lot of plastic surgery -popping up on your page?
-and if that's the case, -you know, maybe unfollow -and there are settings -that you can put -in your social media -to, to not see these things -anymore.
-You can say, don't -show me things like this.
-and maybe seeking out -those more -inclusive resources -on a social media feed.
-So then now your -algorithm might change.
-Bestie, we have -to stop comparing ourselves -to other people.
-Yeah, flowers are pretty, -but so are sunsets.
-And they look nothing -alike.
But.
-I think that we think -a lot of times -that if we don't have like -100,000 followers -on Instagram, like -we can't make a difference.
-But even if you have, -like a thousand followers, -if you have 100 followers, -you're making a difference -just by sharing -other people's voices -who are doing the work.
-of breaking down -body based oppression.
-It's time to stop taking -shots against our own team.
-Yeah, I said it.
-It's time for us to gather -all our players -over to our side and stop -hating on ourselves.
-Stop being so mean -to ourselves.
-Stop not being afraid -to ourselves.
-Stop not being a fan -of ourself - and a fan of our team.
- Okay?
-Advocating for fat people, -you know, in the real -world is just as important -as sharing -any sort of content online.
-for me, -when I have friends who ask -if there is accessible -seating -or they just think ahead -and that makes me feel -so much more -wanted there and -so much more comfortable.
-I remember -I went to my friend's -wedding year two ago and, -these chairs -looked like they were -made out of toothpicks, -and I was terrified.
-And I was like, -I don't want to bug her.
-It's her wedding day.
-But like, I was like, -if I fall through this -chair on our wedding day, -this is going to be -awkward, too.
-So I went over to her -and I was like, hey, -these chairs look like, -really not sturdy.
-And she was like, oh -my God, I already saw them.
-Like.
And I talk to them.
-They're rated for like, -x pounds, like, -is that like, okay.
-And I was like, -oh my gosh.
Yes.
-Like thank you -for like Ross.
-And she was like, -I was so concerned you -because they looked like -they would just -like fall apart -and like -the fact that she made it -comfortable -for other people as well -just was like ten -out of ten, 15 out of ten.
-I think people of any -size can employ some things -to make the world better -for fat people.
-One of those things -is just looking around -you and noticing -how the world is set up -in ways -that do not accommodate -fat people.
-You don't -have to be a fat person -to be the person -who says to your office, -hey, we should have -some armless chairs -around here -because bigger people -come into this space, -right?
-You don't have to leave -that for your fat -colleague to do.
-and that goes -across the board to all kinds of things.
It goes everything from -you're getting married.
-Are your bridesmaids -gowns being purchased -from a place that has -larger size clothing, -or does that bridesmaid -have to pay -100,000 extra dollars -for a custom gown?
-You're going shopping with -your friend who's larger.
-Don't only go to a place -that has a tiny plus size -section in the back -dark corner of the store, -like all of those kinds -of advocacy -things -you can do all the time, -just just turning on -that lens to think about.
-If you haven't -thought about it, why?
-Why don't more fat -people work at your job?
-Is it -because they just don't -happen -to like your industry?
-Or is it -because there's gatekeeping -in your industry -that keeps people out, -like all of those -kinds of things?
-Would -you turn that lens on?
-You can be a good advocate -for fat people -as a fat person, -advocating for yourself, -or as a good member -of the community advocating -for accessibility -for other people.
-I had often told -other people, -you should just tell -the doctor you're -not going to be weighed.
Just tell them you're -not going to be weighed.
-But I hadn't done it myself -then.
-It was -about five years ago.
-I realized, -you know, -that's -kind of -uncomfortable to do, -but if I'm going to tell -other people to do it, -I need to do it myself.
-So I did.
-About five years ago, -I started saying, -I don't get weight, -I don't do that.
-And this is the reason why -that didn't stop them -from asking me -the next time, -the next time -and the next time.
-But eventually, -I think they wrote it -in my chart -because they did -stop asking about it.
-But what was most -instructive for me -is that I needed to live -that experience of what -it's like and and realize -that my doing -that would be so important, -so that in that office, -anyone else who came in -and maybe was afraid -to say something, -that it would help -create the space for others -to be able to do that, to -also just making -fat friends -wherever you are, -whether that's online -or in person or at work -or at school, -everyone deserves friends.
-Everyone wants friends.
-I believe that it's -one of the hardest things -to make friends -as an adult, -especially as a fat person -like you already think -that no one -wants to like, engage with -you because you're fat like -make friends -with fat people.
-The people watching this -and you, yourself -and every resident of this -Commonwealth -has a voice.
-And every single person -in this Commonwealth -is part of this -democratic process.
-Small d democracy -necessitates involvement of -you and everyone watching -and then some.
-If you want to move a bill, -it's not going to move -because I want it to move -or because Representative -Wynn wants it to move -or because of, -you know, any small -handful of legislators.
-It only moves when, -majority and oftentimes -a supermajority -want it to move.
-And the way you get -a supermajority -of legislators -to want something to move -and to elevate it -to a position -where it needs to move, -is by all of you -reaching out -to your own personal state -representatives -and senators, -asking them -to sign on to the bill, -reaching out to legislators -who are in key leadership -positions.
-The chairs of the Judiciary -Committee -saying, please schedule -this bill for a hearing.
-Here's why this bill -is so important to me.
-Reaching out to the Senate -President -and the speaker -of the House, -and people -in other positions -of leadership -in both chambers to say, -please move this bill -to the floor.
-Body size -discrimination -is one of the last -remaining legal bastions -of outright abject -discrimination -in this in the nation.
-And we can fix that here -in Massachusetts, -there's not a bill on Earth -that can prevent people -from having -discriminatory attitudes -or from engaging -in discriminatory actions.
-What it can do is, it can -incentivize institutions -not to discriminate.
-You know, -the threat of punishment -for discrimination -is quite an incentive.
-We shouldn't need that.
-People should do -the right thing -in the first place.
-But that is not -how the world works.
-So it can provide -some incentive -and it can provide -some recourse to you.
-If you have been -discriminated against.
-But just the fact of that, -the fact of knowing -that your -person, your identity -is, is now -it is now -indicated to the community -that it is illegal to -discriminate against you.
-It's symbolically huge.
-It also just -creates a shift -in the cultural narrative -with the government -sanctions -sends a message to people, -and what it disallows -sends a message to people.
-Let's rub the hands -in front of the heart.
-Opening up the eyes, -take a look around -your fellow lovelies, -extending this kindness, -loving kindness -out to one another.
-That's all -we need to do in the world.
-Anything bonus is -just nice to have.
-Bring it back -unto yourself.
-Big breath in.
-Let it go.
-Vermont public, -partnering -with local filmmakers -to bring you -stories made here.
-For more, -visit Vermont public.org.
Made Here is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by the John M. Bissell Foundation, Inc. | Learn about the Made Here Fund