
November 16, 2026
11/17/2026 | 55m 50sVideo has Closed Captions
Rev. John J. Lydon, OSA; Christopher Hale; Robert Kolker; Habiba Nosheen
Rev. John J. Lydon and "Letters from Leo" author Christopher Hale discuss Pope Leo's political message following his South American tour. Author Robert Kolker discusses his book "The Vanishing Family" and the devastating impact of inherited dementia. Filmmaker Habiba Nosheen discusses her film "Gymnasts of the Fisherman Colony" and how gymnastics offers girls in Pakistan hope for a better future.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

November 16, 2026
11/17/2026 | 55m 50sVideo has Closed Captions
Rev. John J. Lydon and "Letters from Leo" author Christopher Hale discuss Pope Leo's political message following his South American tour. Author Robert Kolker discusses his book "The Vanishing Family" and the devastating impact of inherited dementia. Filmmaker Habiba Nosheen discusses her film "Gymnasts of the Fisherman Colony" and how gymnastics offers girls in Pakistan hope for a better future.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Amanpour and Company
Amanpour and Company is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.

Watch Amanpour and Company on PBS
PBS and WNET, in collaboration with CNN, launched Amanpour and Company in September 2018. The series features wide-ranging, in-depth conversations with global thought leaders and cultural influencers on issues impacting the world each day, from politics, business, technology and arts, to science and sports.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship>>> HELLO, EVERYONE, AND WELCOME TO "AMANPOUR & CO."
HERE'S WHAT'S COMING UP.
THE POPE LEAVES HIS MARK ON LATIN AMERICA, FROM URUGUAY TO ARGENTINA TO PERU, WE LOOK AT THE WORDS HE CARRIED FROM THE CATHEDRALS TO THE RAIN FOREST.
>>> AND "THE VANISHING FAMILY."
AUTHOR ROBERT KOLKER BRINGS US THE GRIPPING STORY OF HOW A GROUP OF SIBLINGS IS NAVIGATING THE GENETIC THREAT OF EARLY ONSET DEMENTIA.
>>> PLUS -- >> IT IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT OF EVERY CHILD TO LEARN TO PLAY.
>> "THE GYMNASTS OF FISHERMAN COLONY."
FILM DIRECTOR HABIBA NOSHEEN TELLS HARI SREENIVASAN ABOUT THE PAKISTANI GIRLS PURSUING THEIR DREAMS OF COMPETING IN GYMNASTICS IN A CONSERVATIVE MUSLIM SOCIETY.
>>> "AMANPOUR & CO."
IS MADE POSSIBLE BY -- THE ANDERSON FAMILY ENDOWMENT JIM ATTWOOD AND LESLIE WILLIAMS CANDACE KING WEIR CHARLES ROSENBLUM NORMA C. WARNER AND PAUL D. WARNER MONIQUE SCHOEN WARSHAW THE SYLVIA A. AND SIMON B. POYTA PROGRAMING ENDOWMENT TO FIGHT ANTISEMITISM THE STRAUS FAMILY FOUNDATION THE PETER G. PETERSON AND JOAN GANZ COONEY FUND KOO AND PATRICIA YUEN, COMMITTED TO BRIDGING CULTURAL DIFFERENCES IN OUR COMMUNITIES BARBARA HOPE ZUCKERBERG AND BY CONTRIBUTIONS TO YOUR PBS STATION FROM VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
THANK YOU.
>>> AND A WARM WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM, EVERYONE.
I'M PAULA NEWTON IN NEW YORK, SITTING IN FOR CHRISTIANE AMANPOUR.
POPE LEO HEADS LACK TO THE VATICAN TODAY AFTER A 12-DAY TOUR OF SOUTH AMERICA WHERE HE DELIVERED AN UNMISTAKABLY POLITICAL MESSAGE.
SPEAKING FROM THE PERUVIAN AMAZON ON SUNDAY, THE LEADER OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH ALIGNED HIMSELF WITH ENVIRONMENTALISTS AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLES.
TAKE A LISTEN.
>> UNFORTUNATELY, THE VOICE THAT EMERGES FROM THESE PLACES TODAY SPEAKS TO US OF WOUNDS THAT NOT ONLY HAVE NOT HEALED, BUT HAVE EVEN WORSENED.
THE CRY OF THE EARTH AND THE CRY OF THE POOR RISE TOGETHER, EXPOSING MARKET AND EXPLOITATION LOGICS THAT PUT THE VERY BALANCE OF CREATION AT RISK.
IT'S NOT POSSIBLE TO GUARANTEE --SAFEGUARD THE AMAZON WITHOUT CONCERN FOR THE PEOPLES WHO POPULATE IT.
>> AN ESTIMATED 12 MILLION PEOPLE GATHERING TO SEE HIM RIGHT ACROSS THREE COUNTRIES.
AND IT WAS ALSO SOMETHING OF A HOMECOMING AS HE SPENT YEARS SERVING THE CHURCH IN PERU AND HOLDS CITIZENSHIP THERE.
SO DESPITE HIS RECENT HEALTH TROUBLES, ARE WE SEEING A MORE OUTSPOKEN AND POLITICAL PONTIFF AS WELL EMERGE?
WE WANT TO ASK FATHER JOHN LYDON, WHO WORKED WITH POPE LEO FOR MORE THAN TEN YEARS IN PERU, AND CHRISTOPHER HALE, WHO CHRONICLES THE PAPACY IN HIS SUBSTACK "LETTERS FROM LEO. "
I WANT TO WELCOME YOU BOTH TO THE PROGRAM.
>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING US.
>> THANK YOU.
>> CHRISTOPHER, TO YOU FIRST.
LOOK, TALK ABOUT THE MILES COVERED.
POPE LEO COVERED 20,000 MILES ON THIS TRIP, TRAVELING TO THE POOREST AND SOME DANGEROUS NEIGHBORHOODS AS WELL, PRISONS, MOUNTAINTOPS, AND OF COURSE THE RAIN FOREST.
WHAT MESSAGE, CHRISTOPHER, DID HE SEND WITH THIS VERY AMBITIOUS ITINERARY?
>> YOU KNOW, I THINK WHAT HE REALLY SHOWED US THROUGHOUT THESE 12 DAYS IS NUMBER ONE, THAT THIS IS A POPE WHO UNAFRAID.
YOU SAID IT A MONTH AGO.
POPE LEO THE XIV UNDERWENT LUNG CANCER SURGERY, AND WE WERE AFRAID HE WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO MAKE THIS TRIP.
MANY PEOPLE WERE AFRAID.
THE FACT THAT HE IS OUT THERE SHOWS HE IS A POPE WHO IS WILLING TO GET ENTANGLED WITH THE WORLD AND WILLING TO TRAVEL GREAT LENGTHS, EVEN AMIDST ILLNESS.
BUT WHAT REALLY STRUCK ME ABOUT THIS TRIP, REALLY FOR THE FIRST TIME DURING POPE LEO'S PONTIFICATE, THIS IS A HOPE WILLING TO BE SPONTANEOUS.
WHEN HE FIRST EMERGED FROM THE LOGGIA OF ST.
PETERS, HE WAS A CANON LAWYER.
HE HAD HIS SPEECH PREPARED, ET CETERA.
WE SAW A CANDID POPE IN HIS OWN SKIN, ESPECIALLY IN PERU.
YES, HE HAD A POLITICAL MESSAGE.
BUT I THINK THE BIGGEST MESSAGE WE TAKE AWAY FROM THIS TRIP IS HE WANTS TO, QUOTE JOHN 23 A CHURCH THAT IS POOR FOR THE POOR, A CHURCH FOR THE POOR, A CHURCH FOR THE MARGINALIZED.
I THINK THAT'S A MESSAGE HE REALLY GOT ACROSS THIS TRIP.
>> YEAH, TO REALLY GIVE VOICE TO THOSE WHO WOULD LACK IT, ESPECIALLY AT THIS DAY AND AGE.
FATHER JOHN, LOOK, WE'RE GOING LEAN ON YOU HEAVILY HERE.
YOU'VE KNOWN THE POPE FOR FOUR DECADES, I BELIEVE.
AND THE MESSAGE WE JUST HEARD FROM THE POPE WAS TYING TOGETHER ECONOMIC INJUSTICE, ENVIRONMENTAL CARE AND CONCERN, OF COURSE, FOR INDIGENOUS PEOPLES.
AS I SAID, YOU KNOW THIS MAN SO WELL.
WHAT DO YOU BELIEVE ARE HIS INTENTIONS WITH THESE MESSAGES BEYOND THE OBVIOUS RELIGIOUS TEACHINGS THAT HE BROUGHT WITH HIM?
>> WELL, I THINK THAT THE EMPHASIS COMES FROM THE SAME ROOT WHICH IS THE HUMAN DIGNITY.
IN THE 1990s, WE LIVED TOGETHER IN TOJILLO.
THAT WAS A TIME OF TERRORISM AND HE ORGANIZED MARCHES IN DEFENSE OF HUMAN RIGHTS.
I THINK THAT'S PART OF HIM.
WHEN HE GOES TO THE AMAZON AND SPEAKS ABOUT THE EXPLOITATION OF THE INDIGENOUS PEOPLES, IT COMES FROM THAT SAME ROOT, THE ROOT OF HUMAN DIGNITY AND THE ONES WHO ARE FORGOTTEN IN THAT ARE USUALLY THE PEOPLE ON THE MARGINS, THE POOR.
IN EVERY COUNTRY, HE WENT TO SOME PLACE THAT'S ON THE MARGINS, THE PEOPLE THAT ARE THE POOREST, THE FORGOTTEN PEOPLE.
AND I THINK THAT WAS INTENTIONAL, BECAUSE THAT'S PART OF WHO HE IS, THE VOICE OF THOSE THAT AREN'T HEARD IN OUR SOCIETY.
>> FATHER JOHN, CAN WE EXPECT A VERY ACTIVIST POPE THEN HERE?
DO YOU BELIEVE YOU'RE SEEING THE TRUE FAITH AND FACE OF POPE LEO?
>> YES.
I THINK WE'RE SEEING HIM COMING, GROWING IN THE ROLE OF POPE.
BUT I GO BACK AND SAY THESE ARE THE BASIC VALUES THAT HE SHOWED IN PERU 30 YEARS AGO IN THE 1990s.
SO THERE IS NOTHING SURPRISING TO ME ABOUT THIS.
HE FEELS COMFORTABLE SPEAKING IN LATIN AMERICA.
HE KNOWS LATIN AMERICA, ESPECIALLY PERU.
YOU SAW THAT ON HIS FACE, THE JOY WITH THE PEOPLE, SEEING THEIR DANCES AS HE TALKED ABOUT HER FOOD, THEIR DANCES.
SO HIS DEFENSE OF THE CULTURE OF PERU.
HE'S ALWAYS FELT CLOSE TO THAT.
THEIR MUSIC AND THEIR FOOD.
SO I THINK ALL THOSE UNDERSCORE HIS IDEA OF THE DIGNITY OF THE PERUVIAN CULTURE AND OBVIOUSLY IN THE OTHER COUNTRIES THAT HE VISITED, ARGENTINA AND URUGUAY.
SO I DON'T THINK THERE IS A NEW PERSON HERE.
I THINK HE IS THE SAME PERSON GROWING IN HIS ROLE.
AND BECAUSE HE'S SO FAMILIAR WITH LATIN AMERICA, THERE'S A FREEDOM THAT WAS JUST MENTIONED, MORE SPONTANEOUS FREEDOM TO SPEAK AND TO GIVE REALLY SOME POWERFUL GESTURES OF SOLIDARITY WITH THE POOR AND RESPECT FOR THEIR CULTURE, THE INDIGENOUS CULTURES OF PERU.
VERY, VERY RESPECTFUL ABOUT THAT.
HE TALKED ABOUT THAT A LOT.
>> AS YOU SAID, HE KNOWS THIS SO WELL, HAVING SPENT SO MUCH TIME THERE ALONG WITH YOU.
CHRISTOPHER, POPE LEO CRITICIZED ARGENTINA'S POLITICS AND ITS ECONOMY WHILE STANDING RIGHT NEXT TO PRESIDENT JAVIER MOLAY.
HE TOOK ISSUE WITH MOLAY'S AUSTERITY MEASURES.
I WANT YOU TO LISTEN TO THE POPE NOW.
>> Translator: IN PARTICULAR, I SHARE A THOUGHT FOR THE FAMILIES BURDENED BY UNCERTAINTY, FOR THOSE WHO LOOK FOR A JOB, FOR ELDERLY WHO FOR YEARS HELPED TO BUILD SOCIETY, AND FOR THOSE WHO WHILE WORKING, THEY STRUGGLED TO COVER THE NEEDS IN THEIR HOUSEHOLD.
THE ECONOMY MUST BE AT THE SERVICE OF THE PERSON AND NOT THE PERSON AT THE SERVICE OF THE ECONOMY.
>> NOT THE PERSON IN SERVICE OF THE ECONOMY.
MOLAY ONCE CALLED POPE FRANCIS, HIS PREDECESSOR, THE REPRESENTATIVE OF EVIL ON EARTH.
CHRISTOPHER, WHAT DOES POPE LEO HOPE TO ACCOMPLISH BY BEING SO FORTHRIGHT, SPEAKING WITH SUCH CANDOR THERE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF ARGENTINA?
>> YOU KNOW, WHEN THE POPE'S GOTTEN INVOLVED IN POLITICS IN THE PAST, HE'S BEEN VERY CLEAR THAT HE ONLY GETS INVOLVED IN POLITICS IF IT'S CORE TO THE GOSPEL MESSAGE, TO THE MORAL MESSAGE OF THE CHURCH.
AND FOR HIM AND FOR THE CHURCH, THE DIGNITY OF THE HUMAN PERSON, THE RIGHT TO WORK, TO LAND, TO FREEDOM IS AT THE CORE MESSAGE.
BUT I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS I REALLY WANT TO PICK UP ON IS THIS DEFENSE OF DEMOCRACY IS SOMEWHAT NEW AMONG THE CATHOLIC TRADITION.
POPE LEO THE XIVth IS THE FIRST POPE EVER TO VOTE IN A SECULAR ELECTION.
I THINK WHAT HE IS SAYING IS THESE CORE COMPONENTS OF DEMOCRACY ACTUALLY MUST DELIVER FOR THE PEOPLE.
AND I THINK THAT'S AN INHERENT PART OF THE CATHOLIC IDENTITY THAT HASN'T BEEN EMPHASIZED THAT'S KIND OF COMING TO THE SERVICE IS DEMOCRACY MUST DELIVER FOR PEOPLE.
SO HE TALKS ABOUT HOW WE DO THAT, BUT ALSO WHAT MUST BE DELIVERED.
SO I THINK THE MESSAGE TO JAVIER MOLAY IS A MESSAGE THAT HE CAN EXTEND HERE TO NORTH AMERICA AS WELL, THAT THE RIGHT TO WORK, THE RIGHT TO LAND, THE RIGHT TO HAVE A DIGNIFIED LIFE IS A CORE COMPONENT OF THE CHRISTIAN MESSAGE.
AND I THINK THAT WHAT WE'RE SEEING HERE IS A POPE WHO IS WILLING TO ENGAGE IN THAT WAY, BUT ALSO BE A POPE WHO IS WILLING TO DEFEND IN WORD AND DEED DEMOCRACY.
>> AND WHAT ABOUT THAT, FATHER JOHN?
POPE LEO CRITICIZED ECONOMIC POLICY THAT IN HIS WORDS TENDS TO EXPLOIT NATURE AND CULTURES FOR THE SAKE OF IMMEDIATE ECONOMIC GAIN FOR THE BENEFIT OF ONLY A FEW.
I MEAN, THOSE COMMENTS WERE, OF COURSE, DELIVERED IN PERU YOU SAY HE FEELS QUITE COMFORTABLE.
AND YET DO YOU BELIEVE THAT IS A GLOBAL MESSAGE FOR THIS POPE GOING FORWARD?
>> DEFINITELY IT'S A GLOBAL MESSAGE.
IT'S CLEAR IN HIS RECENT ENCYCLICAL ON HUMAN DIGNITY.
SO THIS IS A CORE TEACHING OF THE CHURCH FOR POPE LEO.
HE IS PUTTING ANOTHER EMPHASIS ON IT BECAUSE OF WHERE HE WAS IN LATIN AMERICA.
BUT I THINK THE DEFENSE OF DEMOCRACY IS VERY STRONG WITH HIM, ESPECIALLY IN PERU.
HE SPOKE ABOUT THAT TO THE AUTHORITIES OF PERU BECAUSE DEMOCRACY WAS SO FRAGILE THERE.
PEOPLE FEEL LIKE IT'S NOT WORKING FOR THEM.
AND SO MANY PRESIDENTS OF PERU HAVE ENDED UP IN JAIL FOR CORRUPTION.
AND SO HE MADE IT VERY CLEAR ABOUT THE VOCATION OF THE POLITICAL CLASS AND THE NEED FOR A CONVERSION, A NEED TO CHANGE.
AND I THINK THAT'S JUST A FUNDAMENTAL VALUE OF HUMAN DIGNITY COMING THROUGH THE DEMOCRATIC PROCESS.
AND COMING FROM THE UNITED STATES, YOU'RE BROUGHT UP IN THAT, BUT IN LATIN AMERICA, THAT HAS NOT BEEN THE HISTORICAL NORM.
AND SO I THINK HE'S EMPHASIZING THAT BECAUSE OF THE YEARS HE SPENT IN PERU AND SUFFERED SEEING THE GOVERNMENTS NOT RESPONDING TO THE PEOPLE.
>> NOW CHRISTOPHER, THE POPE HAS BEEN CALLING OUT THIS RIGHT WING POPULISM.
DOES HE RISK REALLY BEING POLITICALLY ALIGNED IN ANY WAY AND POLITICALLY ALIGNING THE CATHOLIC CHURCH, ESPECIALLY PERHAPS WITH THE SO-CALLED PROGRESSIVE LEFT?
>> SURE.
LET'S BE VERY CLEAR.
THE CATHOLIC CHURCH IS NOT NEUTRAL.
AND MORE IMPORTANTLY, GOD IS NOT NEUTRAL.
GOD HEAVILY CARES ABOUT THE POLITICAL LIFE OF OUR COUNTRY, OF THE WORLD.
AND SO THE CHURCH IS NOT PARTISAN.
POPE LEO XIV EMBODIES THAT.
HE HAS VOTED IN REPUBLICAN AND DEMOCRATIC PRIMARIES IN THE PAST.
THERE IS ALWAYS A RISK OF MARGINALIZATION.
I THINK WHAT HE CEASE, THIS IS MY BELIEF, HE SEES THE BIGGEST THREATS TO DEMOCRATIC RULE, TO CIVILIZATION RIGHT NOW ARE FROM RIGHT WING POPULIST MOVEMENTS, JUST AS JOHN PAUL II SAW DURING THE 1970s AND '80s THAT THE GREATEST THREAT TO THAT GENERATION WAS LEFT WING COMMUNISM.
THE THREATS CAN COME FROM THE LEFT AND THE RIGHT.
IT'S JUST THAT AT THIS TIME AND PLACE, THE MOVEMENTS THAT ARE WORKING AGAINST HUMAN DIGNITY TEND TO COME FROM RIGHT WING POPULIST MOVEMENTS.
JUST AS GOD RAISED UP A POPE FROM BEHIND THE IRON CURTAIN TO HELP DEFEAT COMMUNISM, I THINK GOD HAS RAISED UP POPE FROM BEHIND THE WALL OF AMERICA TO HELP DEFEAT AUTHORITARIANISM AT HOME AND ABROAD.
>> HOW ABOUT THAT, AND THE THOUGHT THAT YOU RAISED POPE JOHN PAUL, THEY DOCUMENTED WHAT HE SAID AND WHAT HE DID DURING THE TIMES HE WAS POPE.
BUT FATHER, POPE LEO MET WITH IMMIGRATION ACTIVISTS FROM CHICAGO BEFORE HE LEFT ROME.
AND THIS, WE ALL REMEMBER IS THE POPE WHO SAYS, AND I'M QUOTING HIM, SOMEONE WHO SAYS I'M AGAINST ABORTION, BUT IN AGREEMENT WITH THE INHUMANE TREATMENT WITH IMMIGRANTS IN THE UNITED STATES.
I DON'T KNOW IF THAT'S PRO-LIFE.
FATHER JOHN, WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THAT?
AND DO YOU BELIEVE HE DOES WALK IN THE TRADITION OF POPE JOHN PAUL?
>> CERTAINLY.
I THINK HE FOLLOWS THE TRADITION OF JOHN PAUL AND PARTICULARLY POPE FRANCIS.
YOU KNOW, FOR 250th ANNIVERSARY OF AMERICAN INDEPENDENCE, HE WENT TO LA PALUZZA, THE LITTLE ISLAND OFF ITALY TO EMPHASIZE MIGRANT RIGHTS, AND TO CRITICIZE THE INDIFFERENCE TOWARDS THEM.
HE CALLED THEM --HE CALLED OUT SOCIETY THAT'S INDIFFERENT TO THE GRAVEYARDS OF THE SEA, A VERY POWERFUL IMAGE.
SO THE DEFENSE OF MIGRANTS AND THEIR HUMAN DIGNITY IS A CORE PRINCIPLE THAT HE'S EMPHASIZING.
IT'S SIMILAR TO POPE FRANCIS.
THEY'RE THE FIRST TWO POPES THAT REALLY HAVE COME OUT STRONGLY ON THE ISSUE OF MIGRATION AS THAT BECOMES A GLOBAL PHENOMENON.
AND THAT'S A PRO-LIFE ISSUE.
IT'S HUMAN LIFE.
THAT'S WHAT HE'S EMPHASIZING, THAT HUMAN LIFE, HUMAN DIGNITY NEEDS TO BE RESPECTED.
HE SAYS HUMAN PEOPLE, HUMAN DIGNITY DOESN'T HAVE A PASSPORT.
EVERYONE IS ENTITLED TO IT.
>> AND AGAIN, HE IS AMPLIFYING THAT WHEREVER HE GOES.
CHRISTOPHER, POPE LEO IS GETTING INVOLVED MORE AND MORE WE BELIEVE IN GEOPOLITICS.
HE PERSONALLY CALLED VLADIMIR PUTIN FROM THE HOSPITAL DURING HIS CANCER TREATMENT.
YOU KNOW, HE WAS PLEADING FOR THAT HUMANITARIAN ASSISTANCE IN OLESKI IN UKRAINE.
HOW MUCH MORE OF THAT WILL WE SEE FROM THIS POPE?
AND CAN IT HAVE A MATERIAL DIFFERENCE IN SOME OF THE TOUGHEST CONFLICTS AROUND THE WORLD?
>> ABSOLUTELY.
THIS IS THE ROLE OF THE PAPAL OFFICE.
I WANT TO REMIND YOU THAT ON THE FUNERAL OF POPE FRANCIS, FAMOUSLY THERE IS THAT BEAUTIFUL IMAGE OF DONALD TRUMP AND VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY IN ST.
PETER'S BASILICA.
AND THAT ACTUALLY RESTART THEIR RELATIONSHIP AFTER THEIR HORRIFIC MEETING IN FEBRUARY 2025 IN THE OVAL OFFICE.
SO THIS IS PART OF THE PAPAL TRADITION.
AND POPE LEO XIV IS TAKING THAT UP.
ONE NOTE THAT IS IMPORTANT.
THERE IS ONE WORLD LEADER WHO HAS NOT CALLED THE POPE DURING HIS 18 MONTHS OF BEING THE POPE, AND THAT IS DONALD TRUMP.
I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT THAT DONALD TRUMP MAKE THAT OLIVE BRANCH OUT.
HE HAS ATTACKED POPE LEO XIV IN THE PAST.
CHOE HAVE AN ALLY IF HE CHOOSES TO IN THE LAST TWO YEARS OF HIS PRESIDENCY, BUT HE NEEDS TO MAKE THAT PHONE CALL.
>> HE NEEDS TO MAKE THAT PHONE CALL.
INTERESTING.
AND A FINAL QUESTION TO YOU BOTH.
AND FATHER JOHN, HE WILL START WITH YOU.
CAN YOU TELL US ABOUT THIS MAN?
I MEAN, HE WAS IN THE HOSPITAL.
HE HAS NOW GONE LITERALLY AND FIGURATIVELY TO NEW ALTITUDES IN LATIN AMERICA.
WHAT IS HE MADE OUT OF?
AND DO YOU BELIEVE PERHAPS THIS DIAGNOSIS, HAS IT ALLOWED HIM TO PERHAPS DOUBLE DOWN ON HIS COMMITMENT TO THESE MISSIONS, NOT JUST RELIGIOUSLY, BUT OBVIOUSLY POLITICALLY AS WELL?
FATHER JOHN, WE WILL START WITH YOU.
>> YES.
I THINK IT'S AMAZING THAT HE WAS ABLE TO GO TO THE ALTITUDES OF CUSCO AND SANTA CRUZ IN PERU.
BOTH HAVE HIGH ALTITUDES.
BUT I THINK HE REALLY WANTED TO --THE PEOPLE IN THE ANDES, THEY'RE THE POOREST AND THE MOST FORGOTTEN.
THEY SPEAK CACHUA.
HE GAVE A MEETING IN KACHUA IN CUSCO.
I THINK HE REALLY WANTED TO EMPHASIZE WE HAVE TO GO OUT TO WHERE THE FORGOTTEN ARE.
AND THAT'S THE ANDES OF PERU.
SO I THINK HE TOOK THE RISK.
I'M SURE WITH SOME MEDICAL, YOU KNOW, SANCTIONING OF IT.
THAT'S ALL RIGHT.
BUT THE FACT THAT HE WENT THERE WAS VERY IMPORTANT TO HIM BECAUSE HE DIDN'T WANT THE PEOPLE ON THE MARGINS TO BE FLOWN OVER, BUT NOW BE VISITED.
>> YEAH.
AND TO MEET THEM WHERE THEY ARE.
FATHER JOHN, DID IT SURPRISE YOU, THOUGH, OR DO YOU THINK THIS IS JUST WHAT THIS MAN IS LIKE?
>> YEAH, IT'S LIKE WHAT HE IS.
HE'S ONE THAT KEEPS PUSHING FORWARD.
HE DOESN'T REALLY SEE A LOT OF OBSTACLES, BUT HE IS A HUMAN BEING.
AND SO I WAS SOMEWHAT SURPRISED.
DURING HIS OPERATION, I WROTE TO HIM AND I SUGGESTED HE MAYBE RECONSIDER BECAUSE OF THE ALTITUDES.
BUT HE HAS DOCTORS.
BUT HE WANTS TO GO FORWARD.
HE'S NOT GOING TO BE HELD BACK UNLESS HIS DOCTORS, YOU KNOW, DICTATE HE BE HELD BACK.
SO THAT'S HIS PERSONALITY.
>> DID THE POPE RESPOND TO SAY I'M FINE, THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONCERN?
>> YES, YES.
YES, HE DID.
YES.
>> FASCINATING.
>> AND HE SAID THE DOCTORS THOUGHT HE COULD GO THROUGH.
AND THAT'S WHAT WAS HIS INTENTION.
MANY BLESSINGS TO HIM FOR DOING IT.
>> INDEED.
HE IMPRESSED SO MANY BY DOING IT, ESPECIALLY THOSE WHO SAW HIM IN PERSON.
AND CHRISTOPHER, THAT QUESTION TO YOU.
GIVEN PERHAPS HE'S BEEN FACED WITH ONE OF THE MOST SERIOUS MEDICAL CONDITIONS HE'S HAD IN HIS LIFETIME, DO YOU THINK IT ADDS MORE URGENCY TO WHAT HIS MISSION IS AS POPE LEO?
>> ABSOLUTELY.
POPE FRANCIS WHEN HE WAS A YOUNG MAN, HE HAD PART OF HIS LUNG REMOVED.
HE TALKS OF THAT BEING A CORE COMPONENT, FACING THE SOBRIETY OF DEATH.
AND IT ENCOURAGED HIM TO GET ON THE MOVE.
WE TALK TIME AND AGAIN ABOUT THIS BEING A LONG PAPACY.
THAT'S UP TO GOD.
THAT IS UP TO THE FAITH THAT IS UP TO THE REALITY OF HIS MEDICAL CONDITION.
BUT MY SENSE OF IT IS THAT WE HAVE A POPE WHO HAS FOUND THE PERUVIAN SIDE OF HIM, FOUND THE MISSIONARY SIDE OF HIM.
HE'S ON THE MOVE.
I THINK THE MOST COMPELLING STORIES OF THE GOSPEL ARE THE DISCIPLES AFTER THEY ENCOUNTERED THE RISEN JESUS.
THEY'RE ALWAYS ON THE MOVE.
THEY MAKE HASTE.
SO WE HAVE A POPE AFTER THIS SCARE, AFTER THAT HEALTH CONCERN, AFTER CANCER WHO IS MAKING HASTE TO SHARE THE GOOD NEWS.
I THINK THAT WILL BE A CORE COMPONENT.
AND I THINK WE SHOULD BE EXCITED HERE IN THE UNITED STATES AND AROUND THE GLOBE TO HAVE SUCH A GOOD MAN AS OUR POPE.
>> UNDENIABLY IN PERPETUAL MOTION, THIS POPE.
CHRISTOPHER HALE, FATHER JOHN LYDON, I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR A FASCINATING DISCUSSION.
REALLY APPRECIATE IT.
>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING US.
>> YOU'RE WELCOME.
PLEASURE.
THANK YOU.
>> SO LISTEN, IF YOU COULD KNOW WHAT YOUR LAST YEARS MIGHT LOOK LIKE, WOULD YOU CHOOSE TO FIND OUT?
FEW PEOPLE GET THE OPPORTUNITY, BUT SOME DO.
IN HIS NEW BOOK, "THE VANISHING FAMILY," THE JOURNALIST ROBERT KOLKER FOLLOWS NINE SIBLINGS, EACH OF WHOM HAS A 50% CHANCE OF HAVING INHERITED THE GENETIC MUTATION WHICH CAUSES FRONTOTEMPORAL DEMENTIA.
IT IS IN FACT A CRUEL DISEASE, DEFINED NOT IN ITS EARLY STAGES LIKE FAMILIAR SYMPTOMS LIKE MEMORY LOSS, BUT INSTEAD ANTI-SOCIAL BEHAVIOR, AND IT FORCES FAMILIES TO GRAPPLE WITH IMPOSSIBLE CHOICES ABOUT LOVE, DEATH, AND RESPONSIBILITY.
ROBERT KOLKER'S BOOK HAS RECEIVED RAVE REVIEWS, AND HE JOINS US NOW FROM NEW YORK.
PLEASURE TO HAVE YOU ON THE PROGRAM.
REALLY APPRECIATE IT.
>> THANK YOU, PAULA.
I'M REALLY GRATEFUL TO TALK TO YOU.
>> I'M GOING TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, THIS WAS A HARROWING READ FOR MANY, AND YET AN IMPORTANT ONE.
I DISCOVERED MANY THINGS IN THE BOOK THAT I DIDN'T KNOW.
AND SO I'LL ASK YOU THESE QUESTIONS BECAUSE I THINK UNFORTUNATELY EVERYONE CAN RELATE TO IT, EVEN IF YOU'RE NOT ING TO IT IN YOUR PERSONAL LIFE.
YOUR BOOK CHALLENGES OUR PRECONCEIVED NOTIONS OF WHAT DEMENTIA LOOKS LIKE.
YOU FOLLOW AN AMERICAN FAMILY, NINE CHILDREN IN PENNSYLVANIA.
THEIR LIVES ARE CHANGED WHEN THEIR MOTHER JEAN DEVELOPS FRONTOTEMPORAL DEMENTIA, AS WE WERE SAYING.
NOW JEAN'S LIFE ESSENTIALLY FALLS APART.
BUT THE UNRAVELING, AND THIS SURPRISED ME DOESN'T FOLLOW WHAT WE THINK WE KNOW ABOUT DEMENTIA.
AT FIRST IT'S HER PERSONALITY THAT CHANGES.
SO TELL US, HOW DOES THIS LEAD TO THE ENTIRE FAMILY HAVING TO FACE A TORTUOUS DECISION ABOUT THEIR OWN LIVES?
>> THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION, PAULA.
IN TERMS OF THIS RARE DEMENTIA, A LOT OF FAMILIES GO UNDIAGNOSED OR MISDIAGNOSED FOR YEARS EVEN DECADES.
IN THIS CASE, JEAN, THE MOTHER OF THE FAMILY, THIS PERFECTLY PUT TOGETHER HARDWORKING ADMIRAL MOTHER, HER PERSONALITY CHANGES COMPLETELY.
BY HER 50s, SHE IS SITTING AT HOME ALONE AND DRINKING.
AND THE LAST THING PEOPLE THINK IS THIS IS DEMENTIA.
THEY THINK IT'S ALCOHOLISM OR DEPRESSION OR A BAD MARRIAGE.
AND THEN SHE DIES OF BREAST CANCER BEFORE SHE CAN BE DIAGNOSED.
SO THE FAMILY MOVES FORWARD IN SHOCK ABOUT THE TRAGEDY.
AND THEN SOME OF THE OTHER CHILDREN START TO GET SYMPTOMS.
THIS IS A STORY THAT IS HARROWING.
IT IS WRENCHING, BUT IN MY MIND, IT'S ALSO INSPIRING FOR WHAT IT SAYS ABOUT HOW THE BRAIN WORKS, BUT ALSO HOW DEMENTIA WORKS AND HOW FAMILIES WORK AND HOW WE CAN BE THERE FOR EACH OTHER.
VIEWERS WHO WORRY ABOUT DEMENTIA, AND I THINK THAT'S EVERYONE, HAVE SOMETHING THEY CAN LEARN HERE ABOUT THIS FAMILY'S INSPIRATIONAL STORY.
>> AND IN FACT IT IS, AGAIN, THE DECISIONS OF THIS FAMILY THAT SO INFORM WHAT WE MIGHT LEARN ABOUT THIS.
THERE IS A 50% CHANCE THAT EACH OF JEAN'S CHILDREN HAS INHERITED THE GENETIC MUTATION RESPONSIBLE FOR HER ILLNESS.
AND FOR THOSE WHO HAVE INHERITED, THEIR CHILDREN UNFORTUNATELY ARE ALSO EXPOSED TO THAT SAME RISK.
WHAT WAS IT LIKE FOR THIS FAMILY TO LIVE WITH THAT UNCERTAINTY?
AND WHAT MORAL OR ETHICAL QUESTIONS DID ALL OF THESE CHILDREN HAVE TO CONSIDER?
>> YEAH, IT ALMOST IS LIKE A GRIM'S FAIRY TALE.
THE WHOLE FAMILY GETS A CRYSTAL BALL THAT THEY CAN LOOK INTO IF THEY WISH, TO LEARN THEIR FUTURE, TO LEARN IF THEY'RE GOING GET AN INCURRABLE FORM OF EARLY ONSET DEMENTIA AS EARLY AS THEIR 40s.
AND SOME DECIDE TO LOOK AT THE CRYSTAL BALL, BUT OTHERS DON'T, BUT THEY CAN'T GET IT OUT OF THEIR MINDS.
IT AFFECTS EVERYTHING ABOUT THEIR LIVES.
THEY FEEL FRAGILE.
THEY FEEL LIKE THEIR FAMILY IS FRAGILE.
THEY CALL SIBLINGS ON THE PHONE AND WONDER IF THIS IS THE PHONE CALL WHERE SOMETHING WILL HAVE CHANGED ABOUT THEM.
AND THEN BECAUSE IT'S DEMENTIA, IT'S SOMETHING ALL OF US ASK.
WHICH IS IF I START TO CHANGE, WILL I EVEN KNOW IT'S HAPPENING AND WILL I STILL BE MYSELF.
THESE ARE QUESTIONS THEY ALL HAVE TO SORT OF FACE TOGETHER.
IT'S AMAZING TO ME THE MANY DIFFERENT RESPONSES THEY HAVE TO THE SAME SITUATION.
I THINK VIEWERS ACTUALLY READERS CAN GO SHOPPING IN A WAY WHEN THEY READ "THE VANISHING FAMILY" AND SAY TO THEMSELVES, I THINK I'LL BE A LITTLE MORE LIKE THIS PERSON, OR MAYBE IF I WERE FACED LIKE, THIS I'D BE A LITTLE MORE LIKE THAT PERSON.
IT'S FUNNY TO ME, I THINK, AS I CONTINUE TO GET TO KNOW THEM THE FEARS THEY HAVE ARE REALLY EXAGGERATED FEARS THAT ALL OF US HAVE.
AND THE LESSONS THAT THEY IMPART ARE LESSONS THAT I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE CAN LEARN FROM.
>> BUT I THINK THE CRUCIAL QUESTION, AS YOU POINT OUT, WOULD YOU WANT TO KNOW?
NOW BARB, THE YOUNGEST SIBLING IS THE ONLY ONE PRESENT REALLY TO SEE HER MOTHER'S FULL DETERIORATION.
SHE THE LAST KID LEFT AT HOME.
SHE COMMITS TO UNDERSTANDING THE DISEASE.
BUT OF COURSE SHE STRUGGLES WITH WHETHER TO FIND OUT FOR HERSELF, RIGHT?
AND WE SEE OTHER SIBLINGS MAKE VERY DIFFERENT DECISIONS.
WHAT DID YOU LEARN ABOUT THEIR DECISIONS AND WHY THEY MADE THEM?
>> IT'S AMAZING TO ME THE DIFFERENCES.
THE STORY OF BARB IS A FASCINATING ONE.
SHE IS REALLY BY THE END SHE'S THE PRIME MOVER TO TRY TO GET THE FAMILY DIAGNOSED.
SHE IS THE ONE WHO REALLY BELIEVES IT'S HEREDITARY, BUT AS SOON AS THEY FIND THIS SPECIFIC MUTATION AND THERE IS A TEST, THAT'S WHEN SHE PUMPS THE BRAKES.
SHE HAS THREE CONCERNS TUMBLING TOGETHER AT ONCE AND CASCADING.
THE FIRST OF COURSE IS THAT HER LIFE WILL BECOME JUST LIKE HER MOTHER'S.
SHE WAS, AS YOU SAID, THE LAST ONE IN THE HOUSE TO WATCH HER MOTHER CHANGE.
THE SECOND IS THAT HER CHILDREN WILL BE RELIVING THE WORST PART OF HER CHILDHOOD.
THEY'LL BE WATCHING THEIR MOTHER DISINTEGRATE AND CHANGE SO DRASTICALLY.
AND THE THIRD ONE IS THE WORST ONE OF ALL THAT, IF SHE HAS IT, THEN AS YOU SAID, THE KIDS HAVE A 50-50 CHANCE.
THEY HAVE THE SAME COIN TOSS OF HAVING IT.
AND THOSE THREE FEARS TAKEN TOGETHER FORCE HER TO SAY HOLD UP, I'M NOT GOING TO GET TESTED JUST YET.
AND SHE WAITS EIGHT YEARS.
AND EVEN WHEN SHE TAKES THE TEST, SHE WAITS ANOTHER YEAR BEFORE EVEN LOOKING AT THE ANSWER.
THIS IS HOW TIED UP IN KNOTS SHE IS ABOUT IT.
>> YEAH, AND THIS IS WHEN I SAY IT'S HARROWING, THAT IT IS HARROWING.
AND YET WE ALL CAN RELATE FOR OBVIOUS REASONS.
I WANT TO ASK YOU, I DIDN'T BELIEVE IT WHEN YOU SAID THE STORY COULD BE INSPIRING AND HOPEFUL.
AND YET THERE IS SOMETHING I FOUND INSPIRING THAT AGAINST THE ODDS, THERE WAS ONE EXAMPLE OF A PARTNER ACTUALLY SAYING THAT, LOOK, ANYTHING COULD HAPPEN TO YOU.
YOU COULD GET HIT BY A BUS TOMORROW.
IT'S OKAY THAT SHE DOESN'T GET TESTED.
>> YES, THAT'S THE STORY OF ONE OF THE NEXT GENERATION, A WOMAN IN HER LATE 20s WHO DECIDES THAT SHE'LL GET TESTED, BUT ONLY AFTER HER WEDDING.
AND HER HUSBAND IS COOL WITH THAT, BUT THE HUSBAND'S FAMILY IS A LITTLE SKEPTICAL.
THEY'RE SAYING TO HIM, HEY, MAYBE YOU SHOULD ENCOURAGE HER TO GET TESTED BEFORE YOU GET MARRIED.
AND HE RESISTS BECAUSE HE UNDERSTANDS WHERE SHE'S COMING FROM.
SHE WANTS TO BE A NORMAL PERSON.
SHE DOESN'T WANT TO SIT AND THINK ABOUT THIS HANGING OVER HER HEAD.
SHE WANTS TO HAVE SOME SEMBLANCE OF A LIFE BEFORE SHE --THIS BECOMES THE CENTER OF HER LIFE.
AND HIS RESPONSE IS MY FAMILY'S GOT GENETIC PROBLEMS TOO.
WE'VE GOT ALL KINDS OF THINGS GOING ON.
AND WE COULD ALL GET HIT BY A BUS TOMORROW.
THIS IS GOING TO BE -- THIS COULD BE THE BIG STORY OF OUR LIVES, BUT THERE WILL BE OTHER BIG STORIES TOO.
AND THAT WAS REFRESHING.
THERE ARE LITTLE MOMENTS LIKE THAT THROUGHOUT THE BOOK WHERE DEMENTIA FEELS A LITTLE LESS STIGMATIZED AND MORE LIKE A VULNERABILITY THAT ALL OF US SHARE.
WE ALL ARE VULNERABLE TO DIFFERENT BRAIN NEURODEGENERATIVE CONDITIONS AS WE GET OLDER.
PAULA, THE BIGGEST THING I LEARNED IS BY THE TIME WE LIVE TO OUR 80s OR 90s, WE MAY HAVE NOT JUST ONE, BUT TWO OR THREE DIFFERENT NEURODEGENERATIVE CONDITIONS GOING TO WORK IN OUR BRAINS.
DEMENTIA IS NOT AN ON/OFF SWITCH.
IT'S A CONTINUUM.
WE'RE ALL VULNERABLE.
WE HAVE COMPLEX BRAINS THAT ARE VULNERABLE TO VARIOUS GLITCHES.
AND MAYBE WE SHOULDN'T BE THINKING OF FOLKS WITH DEMENTIA IN THAT STIGMATIZED WAY.
WE SHOULDN'T BE PUTTING THEM IN A BOX.
WELL, WE ALL CHANGE.
CANCER CHANGES US.
DEPRESSION CHANGES US.
ALL SORTS OF THINGS CAN TRANSFORM OUR PERSONALITIES AS WE GET OLDER.
>> AND IT IS HEARTBREAKING IN WAY AND SOMETHING WE HAVE TO ADJUST TO BECAUSE EVEN DESPITE ALL THE RESEARCH, THERE IS STILL NO CURE AND VERY FEW TREATMENTS, AS YOU POINT OUT.
I DO WANT TO GET TO ANOTHER LAYER OF THIS DISEASE THAT HAS AN IMPACT ON THOSE, THE LOVED ONES AFTER DIAGNOSIS.
I DO WANT TO READ A SHORT PASSAGE FROM THE BOOK, BECAUSE I DO THINK IT'S IMPORTANT.
AND YOU'RE TALKING NOW ABOUT THE VANISHING FAMILY.
>> AND I'M HOPING THAT YOU CAN GIVE US SOME INSIGHT ON WHAT IT'S LIKE TO GRIEVE SOMEONE WHO IS THERE BUT NOT THERE AS THE PERSON YOU REMEMBER, ESPECIALLY FOR THE CAREGIVERS, WHETHER THEY'RE SPOUSES OR THE CHILDREN.
>> THE CARE GIVING ASPECT OF THIS BOOK IS REALLY SOMETHING TO BEHOLD.
MY BREATH WAS TAKEN AWAY LEARNING ABOUT SOME OF THE STORIES THERE.
THERE IS A HUSBAND STAYING WITH A WIFE EACH AS SHE INDULGES IN SOME REALLY EXTREME BEHAVIOR.
AND THEN THE BIG ONE IS A SISTER IN THE FAMILY, SUE, WHO LOOKS AFTER HER SISTER CHRISTY FOR 30 YEARS, FULL-TIME, TAKING CARE OF HER, A SISTER WHO SHE DOES NOT RECOGNIZE ANYMORE.
AND SUE WAS SOMEONE I SPENT A LOT OF TIME WITH WHO I WAS ABLE TO TALK WITH ABOUT THIS PHENOMENON THAT I THINK ALMOST EVERYONE GOES THROUGH, WHERE THE PERSON IN THEIR LIFE WHO HAS DEMENTIA SUDDENLY FEELS MORE LIKE A STRANGER.
AND YOU WONDER HOW DO I RELATE TO THEM, HOW DO I --HOW DO I DECIDE IF MY LOVED ONE IS EVEN STILL THERE, DO YOU MOURN?
AND SUE DID DO SOME MOURNING, BUT SHE ALSO DID SOME RECONNECTING.
SHE HAS A VERY DISCIPLINED DISPOSITION THAT ALLOWS HER TO BE A VERY RESILIENT CAREGIVER, BUT SHE ALSO HAS A VERY OPEN HEART AND BECAME REALLY ENMESHED WITH CHRISTY AND LOVED HER, AND LOVED HER OTHER SIBLINGS, TOOK THEM IN WHEN SHE COULD AS WELL.
AND THIS BECAME THE STORY OF HER LIFE.
I THINK HER STORY ALONE GIVES A LITTLE INSPIRATION.
I'M SORRY TO KEEP SAYING INSPIRING, BUT LOVE IS IN THE TITLE OF THIS BOOK.
FAITH, LOVE AND THE QUEST TO END DEMENTIA.
AND IT REALLY IS ABOUT FAMILY LOVE AND HOW IT TRANSFORMS UNDER DIFFICULT CIRCUMSTANCES.
>> YEAH, WELL TRUST ME, THOSE OF WHITE HOUSE HAVE GONE THROUGH IT LOOK FOR INSPIRATION ANY PLACE WE CAN GET IT.
SO WE HEAR YOU, AND WE HEAR YOU THROUGH THIS BOOK.
I DO WANT TO GET TO THE ISSUE OF AUTONOMY, THOUGH, AND INHERITANCE, BECAUSE SO MANY OF US WONDER THAT IF WE KNEW, LET'S SAY WE WERE IN THE SHOES OF THESE PEOPLE, AND PERHAPS SOME OF US WILL BE, RIGHT, WITH TESTS IN DECADES TO COME, HOW DID THIS FAMILY HANDLE KNOWING?
BECAUSE NOW YOU CAN MAKE MORAL AND LEGAL DECISIONS ABOUT WHEN YOU WANT YOUR LIFE TO END.
NOT IN EVERY JURISDICTION, BUT CERTAINLY IN SOME OF THEM.
I'M WONDERING HOW SOME OF THEM GRAPPLED WITH THAT.
>> THERE ARE SOME WHO MANAGED TO BE WILLING TO HAND OVER POWER OF ATTORNEY AND POWER OF THEIR FINANCES TO LOVED ONES BEFORE THEY GOT TOO FAR GONE, AND THOSE PEOPLE INEVITABLY ARE THE ONES WHO ARE THE BEST OFF BECAUSE THEN THEY -- THE PEOPLE WHO CONTROL THEIR POWER OF ATTORNEY CAN HELP FIND THEM GOVERNMENT CARE, PERHAPS EVEN ASSISTED LIVING, BUT ALL SORTS OF BENEFITS WHERE AS IF YOU NO LONGER HAVE CONTROL, YOU HAVE TO FIND A WAY TO PROVE THAT THE PERSON IS INCAPACITATED AND THE LAWS FOR THAT AND COMMITMENT LAWS ARE CRAZY ALL OVER THE COUNTRY.
ONE OF THE BIG CONVERSATIONS WHEN FTD FAMILIES GET TOGETHER IS TALKING ABOUT COMMITMENT LAWS AND TALKING ABOUT POWERS OF ATTORNEY.
THE FAMILIES, AGAIN, THERE ARE MANY, MANY DIFFERENT STORIES IN THE FAMILY.
THERE IS ONE MAN WHO LIVES IN THE STREET FOR A YEAR AND A HALF BECAUSE WE WON'T BE TAKEN CARE OF.
ANOTHER WOMAN WHO ESTRANGES HERSELF FROM THE FAMILY, BUT THEN FINDS A HUSBAND WHO SEEMS TO BE TAKING GOOD CARE OF HER.
AND THEN THERE ARE FAMILY MEMBERS WHO TALK ABOUT BANDING TOGETHER AND MAYBE BUILDING A COMPOUND ONE DAY AND TRYING TO, YOU KNOW, MAKE FOR EASIER CARE GIVING BY BEING TOGETHER IN SOME WAY.
THE QUESTION OF GOVERNMENT DISABILITY BECOMES A BIG QUESTION, AND THAT OF COURSE IS AN ISSUE WITH ALL FORMS OF DEMENTIA AS WELL.
>> YEAH, WHERE YOU CANNOT FIND A CURE, YOU FIND SOLUTIONS, RIGHT.
AND SO MANY PEOPLE GRASPING FOR THEM AND TRYING TO FIND THE BEST WAY.
YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE MOST POIGNANT PHILOSOPHICAL IDEAS RUNNING THROUGH THIS BOOK IS HOW DEMENTIA CHANGES UNDERSTANDING OF OUR OWN IDENTITY, RIGHT.
IF OUR PERSONALITY CHANGES SO FUNDAMENTALLY, YOU KNOW, AS WE SEE FROM THE CHARACTERS IN THESE BOOKS, ARE WE OURSELVES ANYMORE?
WHAT ARE YOUR PERSONAL REFLECTIONS ON THAT, GIVEN ALL THE RESEARCH YOU DID, ALL THE TIME YOU SPENT TALKING WITH THESE FAMILY MEMBERS?
>> I'VE --I'VE WRITTEN A LOT ABOUT PEOPLE IN CRISIS AND ABOUT FAMILIES IN CRISIS.
I READ A LOT OF NARRATIVE NONFICTION, HEAVILY REPORTED, NOTHING IS INVENTED, WARTS AND ALL STORIES ABOUT PEOPLE GOING THROUGH DIFFICULTIES.
AND I ALWAYS COME AWAY WITH A VERSION OF THE SAME THOUGHT WHICH IS THAT AS A SOCIETY, WE WALL OURSELVES OFF FROM ADVERSITY AND SUFFERING.
WE TELL EVERYBODY WE'RE FINE, BUT WE ALL KNOW THAT IN THE BACKGROUND SOMETHING IS GOING THROUGH ALL OF OUR MINDS.
WE'RE ALL DEALING WITH SOMETHING.
AND SO THE RESPONSE WHEN YOU HEAR SOMEONE IS SICK AND AS YOU SAY WELL, I CERTAINLY HOPE THEY'LL GET BETTER, OR IF THEY HAVE SOMETHING INCURRABLE, WELL, THAT'S AWFUL.
AND THEN YOU JUST PUSH THROUGH THE DAY.
BUT ONE INCORRECT ASPECT OF THAT IS DENYING THE FACT THAT ALL OF US ARE FACING THE SAME LONG-TERM OUTCOME.
AND ALL OF US ARE GOING TO EXPERIENCE ADVERSITY AND SUFFERING.
SO I THINK STORIES LIKE THIS FAMILY'S STORY REALLY HELP PEOPLE PROCESS THOSE ANXIETIES IN KIND OF A DISTANT WAY.
THIS FAMILY'S STORY IS EXTREME AND REALLY DIFFICULT, BUT ANYONE WHO WORRIES ABOUT DEMENTIA CAN READ ABOUT THEM AND MAYBE GIVE THEMSELVES THE SPACE TO THINK ABOUT THE THINGS THEY DON'T THINK ABOUT DURING THE DAY WHEN THEY'RE TRYING TO KEEP ALL THE BAD NEWS AT BAY.
AND SO I DO THINK TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION, I DO THINK THAT PEOPLE ARE STILL THEMSELVES BECAUSE I THINK WE ALL ARE VULNERABLE TO CHANGE.
WE ALL ARE VULNERABLE TO BECOMING INCAPACITATED.
AND JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE HAS FALLEN PREY TO THAT VULNERABILITY IS IN MY MIND NO REASON TO SAY THAT THEY'RE NO LONGER A PERSON, THAT THEY'RE DEAD BEFORE THEY'RE DEAD.
THESE ARE THE TEMPTATIONS -- EVERYONE HAS BEEN TEMPTED TO THINK ABOUT THIS FROM TIME TO TIME ABOUT SOMEONE THEY LOVE WHO IS NOW SUFFERING FROM THESE ILLNESSES.
I THINK IT MAKES A BAD PROBLEM WORSE.
I THINK IT ADDS A FRAMEWORK THAT ADDS TO EARN'S SUFFERING TO DECIDE THAT THEY'RE GONE.
>> ROBERT KOLKER, AUTHOR OF "THE VANISHING FAMILY. "
WE HAVE LEARNED A LOT, AND YET WE HAVE SO MANY QUESTIONS STILL.
I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
>> PAULA, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
>>> NEXT, A STORY OF HOPE AND DEFIANCE FOR TEENAGED GIRLS IN PAKISTAN.
IN A NEW DOCUMENTARY, FILMMAKER HABIBA NOSHEEN FOLLOWS A GROUP OF YOUNG GIRLS PRACTICING GYMNASTICS IN THE MACHAR COLONY.
MOST OF THE POPULATION THERE IS BENGALI, FORCED TO LIVE AS UNDOCUMENTED PEOPLE, MAKING IT DIFFICULT FOR THEM TO WORK OR GO TO SCHOOL.
IN "THE GYMNASTS OF FISHERMAN COLONY," NOSHEEN EXPLORES HOW GIRLS WHO ARE PURSUING THEIR DREAMS WHILE DEALING WITH THE OBSTACLES OF THEIR SOCIETY.
>> NOSHEEN JOINS HARI SREENIVASAN.
>> PAULA, THANKS.
HABIBA NOSHEEN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US.
YOU ARE THE FILMMAKER BEHIND A FILM CALLED "THE GYMNASTS OF FISHERMAN COLONY. "
I WANT YOU TO KIND OF SET THE SCENE A LITTLE BIT.
THIS IS A COMMUNITY THAT IS KIND OF ON THE OUTSKIRTS OF KARACHI, PAKISTAN.
IT'S CALLED MACHAR COLONY, RIGHT.
AND WHAT IS UNIQUE ABOUT THESE PEOPLE, BEFORE WE GET INTO THE STORY ABOUT THE GYMNASTICS AND THE YOUNG WOMEN?
>> SO MACHAR COLONY IS A COMMUNITY THAT IS PREDOMINANTLY OCCUPIED BY PEOPLE WHO ARE STATELESS.
AND THEY'RE STATELESS NOT BECAUSE NECESSARILY THEY ARE NOT ENTITLED TO CITIZENSHIP.
IT'S JUST BECAUSE OF THE DISCRIMINATION THAT MANY BENGALIS LIVING IN PAKISTAN CONTINUE TO FACE THAT ULTIMATELY JUST RESULTS IN WHENEVER THEY GO TO TRY TO GET A PASSPORT OR TRY TO GET THEIR CITIZENSHIP PAPER OR ID CARD, THERE IS JUST ONE OBSTACLE AFTER ANOTHER PUT IN FRONT OF THEM THAT JUST RESULTS IN THEM NOT BEING ABLE TO GET THEIR DOCUMENTATION THAT THEY NEED FOR VIRTUALLY EVERY PART OF LIFE IN PAKISTAN.
SO THAT'S THE COMMUNITY THAT THIS FILM IS BASED ON.
>> SO PAKISTAN HAS THE EQUIVALENT OF BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP, AND THESE PEOPLE THAT ARE DISENFRANCHISED, MARGINALIZED, POOR, DON'T HAVE THE LEGAL AID AND EVERYTHING ELSE TO TRY TO FIGHT FOR THEMSELVES IN COURTS?
IS THAT WHAT THE GAP IS?
>> YEAH, EXACTLY.
A CHILD BORN IN PAKISTAN HAS THE RIGHT TO A PAKISTANI CITIZENSHIP.
BUT WHAT I WITNESSED WHILE MAKING THIS DOCUMENTARY IS WHEN THE PARENT WOULD GO TO THE PASSPORT OFFICE OR THE ID OFFICE TO SAY MY DAUGHTER, MY SON NEED THEIR PASSPORT OR THEIR BIRTH CERTIFICATE.
>> YEAH.
>> MOST OFTEN THAN NOT THEY'RE TOLD BRING YOUR BIRTH CERTIFICATE, YOUR GRANDPARENTS BIRTH CERTIFICATE.
SO ALL THESE ADDITIONAL FAMILY DOCUMENTATIONS THAT THEY'RE BEING ASKED TO PROVIDE IN ORDER TO GIVE THE CHILD THEIR BIRTH CERTIFICATE.
AND THOSE ARE THE KINDS OF THINGS THAT ULTIMATELY RESULT IN A HUGE POPULATION OF PEOPLE BEING UNDOCUMENTED BECAUSE OF THE DISCRIMINATION.
>> TELL US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHAT LIFE IS LIKE FOR THESE YOUNG GIRLS AND WOMEN THAT ARE DOING GYMNASTICS.
BECAUSE WE SEE A LITTLE BIT OF THE STREETS.
WE SEE, YOU KNOW, RELATIVELY FREQUENT POWER CUTS.
HOW DO THEY LIVE?
>> POWER CUTS ARE PART OF PAKISTAN.
CAN'T GET AWAY FROM THAT, NO MATTER WHAT SOCIO-ECONOMIC CLASS YOU MIGHT BELONG TO.
BUT GYMNASTICS IS THEIR LIFE, RIGHT.
THEY STARTED TO GO TO THIS SCHOOL.
IT IS A SCHOOL THAT WAS STARTED TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE EDUCATION FOR CHILDREN IN THIS COMMUNITY.
AND ONE OF THE WAYS IT'S DOING THAT IS MOST SCHOOLS WHEN THEY REGISTER UNDER THE LAW WOULD BE REQUIRED TO ASK THE STUDENTS FOR THEIR DOCUMENTATION, WHICH MEANS THIS COMMUNITY THAT DOESN'T HAVE DOCUMENTATION CAN'T SEND THEIR KIDS THERE.
SO THEREFORE, THE WOMAN WHO STARTED THE SCHOOL, BARA AZAN, WHO IS AN AMAZING HUMAN RIGHTS LAWYER, ONE OF THE WAYS SHE THOUGHT ABOUT SOLVING THIS PROBLEM IS TO START A SCHOOL THAT DOESN'T REQUIRE REGISTRATION FOR CHILDREN.
SO THE KIDS START IN THE SCHOOL TO LEARN TO READ AND WRITE.
AND THEN THERE IS A GYMNASTICS PROGRAM BEING DONE BY THE BOYS.
AND THE GIRLS LOOK AT THIS AND SAY WE WANT TO DO THIS.
>> THE GYMNASTICS TEAM CAME ABOUT BECAUSE IN THE BEGINNING WE BEGAN WITH THE BOYS GYMNASTICS TEAM.
WE HAD NOT EVEN THOUGHT OF THE GIRLS AT THAT POINT.
BECAUSE WE WERE OBVIOUSLY IN A SETTING WHERE WE COULD NOT HAVE RAISED THAT AS AN OPTION.
AND AT THAT POINT, BECAUSE THE GIRLS HAD BEEN WATCHING THE BOYS TRAIN FOR A YEAR, YEAR AND A HALF, WE HAD THE GIRLS COME TO US AND SAY WHY CAN'T WE DO THIS?
>> TELL ME A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT CONVINCING PROCESS, BECAUSE THIS IS A CULTURE THAT REALLY, THE WOMEN ARE NOT REALLY SUPPOSED TO OCCUPY SPACE WITH THEIR BODIES.
HOW DID, YOU KNOW, THIS SCHOOL CONVINCE THE PARENTS THAT THE GIRLS SHOULD DO GYMNASTICS?
>> I MEAN, I FOUND THAT TO BE THE MOST INTERESTING PART OF MAKING THIS DOCUMENTARY ABOUT HOW IS IT THAT THESE GIRLS WERE ABLE TO CONVINCE THIS COMMUNITY TO --AND AS YOU MENTIONED, THEY ARE A CONSERVATIVE MUSLIM COMMUNITY.
SO MOST OF THE GIRLS WHEN THEY ARE NOT IN THE SCHOOL SPACE ARE WEARING A BURQA TO COME IN AND OUT OF THE SCHOOL.
SO IT'S A PRETTY CONSERVATIVE COMMUNITY.
AND YET SOMEHOW THESE GIRLS FIGURE OUT A WAY TO CONVINCE THEIR PARENTS, TO CONVINCE THEIR COMMUNITY TO LET THEM DO GYMNASTICS.
AND I THINK THAT SHOWS TO ME ALL THE LITTLE WAYS GIRLS ALL OVER PAKISTAN ARE MAKING THESE DEMOCRATIC SPACES FOR THEMSELVES.
ONE OF THE WAYS I THINK THE SCHOOL DOES SUCCESSFULLY INTEGRATES THE GYMNASTICS PROGRAM IS IT HIRES PEOPLE FROM WITHIN THE COMMUNITY TO WORK.
WHILE WE WERE FILMING, ONE OF THE GIRLS WHO IS A GYMNAST, HER FATHER WAS A SECURITY GUARD AT THE SCHOOL.
SO THE SCHOOL ALSO BECOMES A WAY TO PROVIDE EMPLOYMENT FOR THE COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHO STRUGGLE WITH FINDING EMPLOYMENT.
SO THOSE ARE THE WAYS THAT I THINK THE COMMUNITY REALLY WAS ABLE TO SEE THIS IS NOT SOMETHING TO BE FEARED.
BUT I THINK IT WAS THE UTTER DETERMINATION OF THESE GIRLS.
THEY WERE GOING TO DO THIS, AND THEY WERE GOING TO FIGURE OUT A WAY.
AND ONE GIRL TALKS ABOUT IN THE FILM, INITIALLY HER MOM LOCKED HER UP IN THE HOUSE AND SHE FIGURED OUT.
I NEED 20 DO THIS, I NEED TO GET ANY DAD ON MY SIDE.
ALL THESE POLITICKING THESE TEENAGED GIRLS ARE DOING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO CONVINCE THEIR PARENTS TO LET THEM DO GYMNASTICS.
>> AND I GUESS IF SOMEBODY'S DAD OR SOMEBODY'S MOM IS WORKING AT THE SCHOOL, MAYBE THE COMMUNITY FEELS LIKE WELL, WE'VE GOT EYES ON THEM.
>> EXACTLY.
>> WE KNOW THERE IS NOT SOMETHING WEIRD GOING ON.
>> BUT THE OTHER THING IS THIS COMMUNITY HAS BEEN INVISIBLE IN THE EYES OF MANY PAKISTANIS FOR DECADES.
AND WHEN THE GYMNASTICS TEAM AND THE GIRLS IN THE GYMNASTICS TEAM BECOME KIND OF LIKE LOCAL CELEBRITIES, THEY REALLY USE THEIR PLATFORM TO TELL THE WORLD, TELL THEIR COMMUNITY, TELL PAKISTANIS ABOUT THEIR PLIGHT AS PEOPLE WHO ARE STRUGGLING WITH DOCUMENTATION.
SO THE COMMUNITY THEN BECOMES TO SEE HOW USEFUL THE GIRLS CAN ALSO BE BECAUSE THEY'RE REALLY USING THEIR PLATFORMS STRATEGICALLY TO GIVE VOICE TO THE STRUGGLES OF THEIR PARENTS AND THEIR GRAND PARENTS WHO HAD BEEN RENDERED INVISIBLE FOR DECADES, AND NOW FINALLY THEY'RE ON TV TALKING ABOUT THESE ISSUES.
SO I THINK THE COMMUNITY THEN BEGINS TO SEE HOW THEIR NEWFOUND FAME IS ACTUALLY SOMETHING THAT COULD BE USEFUL FOR THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY.
>> LET'S TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT ONE OF THE MAIN CHARACTERS, SONIA.
SHE IS A 15-YEAR-OLD.
BY TIME WE'RE KIND OF -- WE'RE REALLY WATCHING HER GROW THROUGH THE FILM, BECAUSE IT TOOK YOU DIFFERENT TRIPS TO DOCUMENT ALL THIS, AND HOW SHE IS GROWING THROUGH THIS PROCESS.
>> TELL ME A LITTLE BIT ABOUT HER.
>> YEAH, SONIA IS INCREDIBLY VIBRANT PAKISTANI TEENAGER.
WHEN WE BEGIN FILMING WITH HER, SHE IS 13, AND THE FILM FOLLOWS HER OVER THE COURSE OF THREE YEARS.
HER OLDER SISTER ALSO DOES GYMNASTICS.
AND PART OF THE FILM TALKS ABOUT THEIR COMPETITIVENESS WITH EACH OTHER.
INITIALLY, WHEN HER OLDER SISTER STARTS WINNING TROPHIES, SHE ACKNOWLEDGES THERE IS A SENSE OF RESENTMENT, AND SHE DIDN'T LIKE THAT VERY MUCH.
BUT THEN THAT PUSHES HER TO TRY HARDER.
AND THIS, YOU KNOW, THE THING THAT REALLY IS AMAZING ABOUT SONIA IS HER COMMITMENT TO GYMNASTICS IS REALLY --SHE LOOKS AT IT AS A WAY THAT SHE MIGHT BE ABLE TO BREAK AWAY FROM THE POVERTY THAT HER FAMILY HAS LIVED IN.
SO SHE REALLY SEES THIS AS AN OPPORTUNITY IF SHE DELIVERS ON IT WELL, SHE WOULD BE ABLE TO PERHAPS USE THIS AS A WAY OF EMPLOYMENT, THAT SHE MIGHT BE ABLE TO EARN MONEY TO HELP SUPPORT HER FAMILY.
YOU KNOW, HER MOM WORKS AS A PLAIN PERSON AND HER DAD AS A DAY LABORER.
SO THE FAMILY HAD VERY FEW RESOURCES, AND EVERY MONTH IT WAS A STRUGGLE.
SO SHE STARTS TO SEE GYMNASTICS AS A WAY OUT OF THE SITUATION, TO BE ABLE TO HELP AND SUPPORT HER FAMILY FINANCIALLY.
BUT NEAR THE END OF THE FILM, YOU REALLY SEE HER COME TO HER OWN AND REALLY OWN THE SPACES THAT SHE'S ENTERING.
AND WITH A LOT MORE CONFIDENCE.
AND THAT IS WHY I THINK WHAT THE FILM TRIES TO SHOW IS THE IMPORTANCE OF SPORTS IN THE LIVES OF GIRLS.
THE CONFIDENCE SHE HAS GAINED IN PERFORMING AND BEING IN PUBLIC SPACES COMES FROM THE FACT THAT SHE'S BEEN DOING GYMNASTICS AND PERFORMING IN FRONT OF AN AUDIENCE.
AND THE CONFIDENCE THAT GIVES YOUNG GIRLS OF ALL WALKS OF LIFE, IT'S REALLY AMAZING.
SO I THINK YOU SEE THAT BY WATCHING THE FILM.
YOU SEE THAT HOW HER PARTICIPATION IN GYMNASTICS IS REALLY HAVING AN AFFECT ON HER OVERALL EXISTENCE WHERE SHE BECOMES A MUCH MORE VIBRANT WOMAN, FRANKLY, BY THE END OF THE FILM.
>> WE SEE ALL THE KIND OF INTERSECTIONS OF DIFFERENT PARTS OF PAKISTANI CULTURE AND SOCIETY AS WELL.
WE HAVE A COUPLE CHARACTERS WHO ARE GETTING MARRIED AT WHAT THE WEST WOULD CONSIDER VERY YOUNG AGES, BUT TO THEIR FAMILIES, IT'S PERFECTLY ACCEPTABLE.
AND THEY KIND OF WITHDRAW FROM GYMNASTICS BECAUSE A WHOLE DIFFERENT SET OF CONSIDERATIONS ARE IN EFFECT.
>> YEAH.
YOU KNOW, I THINK IT'S --UNLESS YOU'VE BEEN IN PAKISTAN AND LIVED THROUGH THAT, I THINK IT'S --SOMETIMES IT'S EASY TO FORGET HOW INTEGRAL MARRIAGE IS IN PAKISTANI SOCIETY, ESPECIALLY IN A COMMUNITY AND IN A COUNTRY THAT HAS VERY FEW SOCIAL RESOURCES.
THE MARRIAGE BECOMES A WAY TO MAKE SURE EVERY PERSON IS TAKEN CARE OF, BECAUSE UNLESS YOU'RE MARRIED, THE FEAR IS, WELL, IF SOMETHING HAPPENS TO THE PARENTS, THERE IS NO SOCIAL NETWORK THAT WILL SAVE YOU AND PROTECT AND BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU FOOD AND SHELTER.
SO MARRIAGE IS A VERY UNIQUE PART OF LIFE IN THE WAY THAT PAKISTANI SOCIETY IS.
AND THAT'S KIND OF HOW I LEARNED FROM THE COMMUNITY AND SORT OF TRY TO SHOW THIS WITH HONESTY AND SOME OF IT'S HARD TO WATCH BECAUSE AS A MOM AND AS A WOMAN, YOU HAVE IDEAS ABOUT WHAT SHOULD HAPPEN TO THE LIVES OF GIRLS.
BUT ALSO I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT AS A DOCUMENTARY FILM MAKER TO SHOW THE REALITY AS IS, BECAUSE I THINK THOSE CONVERSATIONS ARE WORTH HAVING.
WHAT I ALSO NOTICED WHEN GIRLS START TO MAKE MONEY, THE AGE OF MARRIAGE CHANGES SIGNIFICANTLY.
AND IT'S BECAUSE THE COMMUNITY THEN STARTS TO SEE YOU NOT AS A BURDEN BUT AS A CONTRIBUTING MEMBER OF SOCIETY AND THEREFORE IT IS IN THE BENEFIT OF THE ENTIRE FAMILY UNIT FOR YOU NOT TO GET MARRIED.
SO I THINK IF WE WANT TO TACKLE EARLY MAGIC FOR GIRLS, THE BEST WAY WE CAN DO THAT IS TO THINK OF HOW DO WE MAKE THEM ECONOMICALLY DEPENDENT ON THEMSELVES.
AND THAT USUALLY STARTS WITH EDUCATION.
BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT THE GIRLS IN THE DOCUMENTARY HAVE BEEN ABLE TO GET AN EDUCATION, IT MAKES THEM MORE EMPLOYABLE.
>> THERE IS ALSO A KIND OF INTERESTING MOMENT DURING THE COMPETITIONS WHERE YOU NOTICE OR WHAT I NOTICE IS THAT ALL THE JUDGES ARE MEN.
AND IT WAS LIKE ON THE ONE HAND, YOU A SOCIETY THAT, YOU KNOW, FROWNS UPON MEN GAZING ON OTHER WOMEN WHO ARE NOT SORT OF FULLY COVERED UP.
AND ON THE OTHER HAND, IT'S ALL GUYS, ALL THE COACHES, EVERYBODY ELSE EXCEPT FOR THIS ONE FEMALE JUDGE, IT WAS REALLY JUST KIND OF STRIKING TO ME, HUH.
THERE'S CLEARLY LIKE SOME SORT OF ACCEPTANCE THAT THIS IS OKAY FOR MEN TO BE IN THIS POSITION.
>> GYMNASTICS HAS TYPICALLY BEEN A MALE SPORT IN PAKISTAN.
SO THAT'S WHERE THE WOMAN WHO STARTED THE SCHOOL SEES OPPORTUNITY FOR GIRLS IF THEY CAN LEARN TO BE GYMNASTS AND LATER ON TO BE COACHES.
THAT BREAKS THAT, YOU KNOW, THE WAY THINGS HAVE BEEN.
IT PUTS MORE FEMALE COACHES IN THE SPACE WHERE THEY SHOULD BE MORE FEMALE COACHES.
I THINK THAT EVERYBODY AGREES THAT IN FACT, I THINK MORE FEMALES WOULD DO GYMNASTICS IF THEY WERE BEING TAUGHT BY FEMALE COACHES.
AND THAT'S AN OPPORTUNITY TO BREAK THE CYCLE OF ALL MALE GYMNASTS WHO ARE THE JUDGES IN THESE COMPETITIONS.
>> YEAH.
TAHERA HASSAN, THE HUMAN RIGHTS LAWYER, SHE KIND OF ARGUES THAT SPORTS FOR GIRLS SHOULD BE FRAMED ALMOST AS A HUMAN RIGHT.
WHY DOES THAT MATTER?
>> YEAH, I HAD NOT HEARD THAT ARGUMENT BEFORE I MET HER.
AND I WAS REALLY TAKEN BY THAT.
I THINK FOR HER, YOU KNOW, SHE WORKS A LOT WITH CHILDREN WHO ARE MARGINALIZED.
AND SHE SAYS WE HAVE THIS UNDERSTANDING THAT AS LONG AS IF YOU'RE FROM A POOR FAMILY, AS LONG AS YOU'RE GIVEN THREE MEALS A DAY AND YOU CAN LEARN TO READ AND WRITE, WE'VE DONE OUR JOB.
WE CAN WASH OUR HANDS AND SAY OKAY, WE'VE DONE WELL FOR THIS CHILD.
BUT SHE SAID THAT'S WHERE WE'RE WRONG.
IT IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT OF EVERY CHILD TO LEARN TO PLAY AND TO THINK ABOUT THEIR OPPORTUNITIES THAT CAN ONLY HAPPEN WHEN YOU GIVE A CHILD THE FREEDOM TO PLAY.
AND THAT'S WHY THE SCHOOL IS CALLED KAIL, WHICH IS THE WORD FOR PLAY.
I'M A BELIEVER.
IT'S MAKING ME THINK ABOUT HOW WE APPROACH PLAY, ESPECIALLY FOR GIRLS AND ESPECIALLY IN PLACES LIKE PAKISTAN AND THE IMPORTANCE IN ADVOCATING FOR THAT.
>> TELL US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT HOW PERSONAL THIS FILM IS TO YOU.
YOU MOVED TO CANADA AT THE AGE OF 9 AS A REFUGEE.
>> YEAH.
>> AND HERE YOU ARE FILMING THESE 9-YEAR-OLDS, 12-YEAR-OLDS, 15-YEAR- OLD GIRLS.
HOW DID YOUR LIFE EXPERIENCE PLAY INTO WHAT YOU WERE SEEING?
>> I THINK I UNDERSTAND ON A VERY DEEP LEVEL WHAT IS IT LIKE TO BE A CHILD WHO LOVES A COUNTRY THAT MAY NOT LOVE YOU BACK.
AND I HOPE COMES THROUGH IN THE FILM TO SHOW THE JOURNEY OF THESE GIRLS WHO REALLY JUST ALL THEY WANT WAS TO FEEL LIKE THEY BELONGED TO A COUNTRY THAT THEY LOVE.
AND LIFE SOMETIMES DOESN'T WORK OUT THAT WAY.
BUT IT'S A FILM THAT REALLY ALLOWS YOU ISSUES OF BELONGING, WHO BELONGS WHERE AND PUSHING TO BELONG TO PLACES THAT MAY NOT WANT YOU.
SO I DEFINITELY THINK MY ISSUE, MY OWN JOURNEY AS A REFUGEE KID HELPED ME TELL THE STORY IN A WAY THAT MAY HAVE BEEN DIFFERENT IF I HADN'T HAD THAT EXPERIENCE.
>> YOU'RE AN INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALIST.
THIS IS NOT THE TYPE OF WORK THAT YOU USUALLY DO, RIGHT?
>> YEAH.
>> USUALLY YOU ARE DOING STORIES THAT YOU'RE NOT NECESSARILY SHARING WITH YOUR OWN KIDS.
SO WHY THIS KIND OF STORY, WHY NOW?
>> IN 2023, WHEN I STARTED WORKING ON THIS, I WAS LOOKING AT MY OWN WORK AND, YOU KNOW, BEEN DOING THIS FOR TWO DECADES.
MOST OF MY WORK DOES FOCUS ON GENDER ISSUES, BUT I WAS CRITICAL OF THE WORK I HAD DONE.
I WAS INCREDIBLY PROUD OF IT.
BUT TAKEN AS A WHOLE WE ARE NOT TELLING STORIES THROUGH CINEMA OR IN JOURNALISM THAT REALLY CENTER ON THE EXPERIENCES OF BROWN WOMEN AND A PERSPECTIVE OF JOY.
THEY ARE CHANGE MAKERS AND HOW THEY ARE SHAPING AND CHANGING THEIR COMMUNITIES.
WE ARE NOT TELLING THOSE STORIES.
SO I INTENTIONALLY SET OUT TO MAKE THIS DOCUMENTARY THAT I WISH EXISTED WHEN I WAS A TEENAGER.
>> SO WHAT DID THE GIRLS THINK WHEN YOU SHOWED THEM THE FINISHED FILM?
>> YEAH, SO SONIA --THE FILM PREMIERED AT TRIBECA, AND SONIA WAS ABLE TO JOIN US AT THE PREMIERE AND JOIN US FOR THE Q&A.
AND RIGHT BEFORE THEY -- WE WERE ABOUT TO GO ON STAGE, SHE TOLD ME SHE HAD NEVER BEEN TO A MOVIE THEATER BEFORE.
AND THIS IS THE FIRST FILM SHE WAS SEEING.
YOU KNOW, IT'S HARD FOR THAT NOT TO DO SOMETHING TO YOU.
I THINK I HOPE THAT THESE GIRLS RECOGNIZE THAT THE WAY THAT THE WORLD HAS EMBRACED THEIR STORY AND THEY DESERVE THAT.
AND I KNOW THAT THEIR CHILDREN WILL HAVE A MUCH BETTER LIFE BECAUSE OF THE THINGS THAT THEY HAVE HAD TO FIGHT FOR IN THEIR OWN COMMUNITY AND THEIR OWN FAMILIES.
>> DIRECTOR AND PRODUCER NOSHEEN, THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
> >> THE HEIST THAT LIFTED SOME OF FRANCE'S MOST VALUABLE CROWN JEWELS, FRENCH MUSEUMS HAVE TAKEN A BEATING.
ONE IS FIGHTING BACK.
IN ORLEAN HAS BEEN STICKING THESE WANTED POSTERS ALL OVER WALLS AND THE INTERNET, TRYING TO INSPIRE AN ARMY OF ART HUNTERS TO TRACK DOWN SOME 400 WORKS THAT DISAPPEARED DURING THE WORLD WAR II NAZI OCCUPATION OF FRANCE.
THE CAMPAIGN ALREADY PAYING DIVIDENDS.
ONE OF THE MISSING MASTERPIECES WAS DISCOVERED IN AN ONLINE AUCTION.
THE PAINTING KNOWN AS UN BUVOUR, OR A DRINKER WILL SOON BE RETURNING TO ORLEAN.
NOW THAT'S SOMETHING THAT IS CERTAINLY WORTH TOASTING.
> >> AND THAT'S IT FOR OUR PROGRAM TONIGHT.
IF YOU WANT TO FIND OUT WHAT'S COMING UP ON THE SHOW EACH NIGHT, SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER AT PBS.
ORG/AMANPOUR.
THANK YOU FOR WATCHING AND GOODBYE FROM NEW YORK.
>>> "AMANPOUR & CO."
IS MADE POSSIBLE BY -- THE ANDERSON FAMILY ENDOWMENT JIM ATTWOOD AND LESLIE WILLIAMS CANDACE KING WEIR CHARLES ROSENBLUM NORMA C. WARNER AND PAUL D. WARNER MONIQUE SCHOEN WARSHAW THE SYLVIA A. AND SIMON B. POYTA PROGRAMING ENDOWMENT TO FIGHT ANTISEMITISM THE STRAUS FAMILY FOUNDATION THE PETER G. PETERSON AND JOAN GANZ COONEY FUND KOO AND PATRICIA YUEN, COMMITTED TO BRIDGING CULTURAL DIFFERENCES IN OUR COMMUNITIES BARBARA HOPE ZUCKERBERG AND BY CONTRIBUTIONS TO YOUR PBS STATION FROM VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
THANK YOU.
>> YOU'RE WATCHING PBS.
Pakistan’s Forgotten Girls Are Finding Their Voice Through Gymnastics
Video has Closed Captions
Filmmaker Habiba Nosheen discusses how gymnastics offers hope to teenage girls in Pakistan. (18m 49s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.


New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
