
New PBS Docuseries Explores the US Criminal Justice System
Clip: 11/16/2026 | 8m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
“Crime and Punishment in America” by documentarian Lynn Novick debuts Monday night.
“Crime and Punishment in America,” a new series from documentarian Lynn Novick, chronicles how the country constructs, consumes and contradicts its own justice system, from failures to deliver rehabilitation in prison to the public’s obsession with true crime.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Chicago Tonight is a local public television program presented by WTTW
WTTW video streaming support provided by members and sponsors.

New PBS Docuseries Explores the US Criminal Justice System
Clip: 11/16/2026 | 8m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
“Crime and Punishment in America,” a new series from documentarian Lynn Novick, chronicles how the country constructs, consumes and contradicts its own justice system, from failures to deliver rehabilitation in prison to the public’s obsession with true crime.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Chicago Tonight
Chicago Tonight is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.

WTTW News Explains
In this Emmy Award-winning series, WTTW News tackles your questions — big and small — about life in the Chicago area. Our video animations guide you through local government, city history, public utilities and everything in between.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAmerican Criminal Legal system has been through reform after reform.
>> From the early days of public executions to the modern-day system of mass incarceration.
A new series from documentarian over chronicles how the country constructs consumes and contradicts its own justice system from failures to deliver rehabilitation in prison to the public's obsession with true crime.
Here's a look.
>> When they get incarcerated, they don't see being human being.
>> In the wake of people who more fine.
>> Was to look at something and recognize the potential danger.
>> I understand wanting punishment as a victim.
But what if more options were available?
>> And here to talk about her forthcoming series is writer, director and producer Leno that Clinton.
Thanks for joining us.
Thank you so much for having me.
So you open the series on public executions that are happening in 18 Th-century America and how one historian said that there is, quote, a very good chance that most people witnessed a public execution in their lifetime.
Fast forward to last month, defense secretary or war Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that there would be a live execution of the Fort Hood shooter then Donald Trump, of course, the president called that off.
I tell that to ask, you know, from historians that you spoke with, do you get the sense that we've regressed as a country through when we think about punishment?
Wow, you know.
There's time when we make progress in the times and we regress.
And when you're any particular moment, may be hard to tell where you are, way the tide is turning.
>> That moment was pretty horrifying to many Americans.
And I'm glad that administration decided not to go through with a live stream of execution and it does speak to.
Our fascination with.
With punishment and with wanting to see justice done.
to me, that wasn't just us.
But I think for a lot of this is so hard to say, you know what was driving that idea was that a lot of people want to CA punishment administered and we invented prisons and penitentiaries in this country.
In the early 19th century because there was a sense that punishing people in public brutally punishing torturing and executing people for crowds to watch was actually bad for society as a whole.
It was degrading.
It was bringing out negative emotions and disorder and chaos and that we wanted to come up with a better system.
But we can't help the people who had committed crimes to better themselves.
And that was called the penitentiary.
>> As we mentioned, America's criminal justice system, it seems like it's been in perpetual reform, you know, to start from the public executions that formed our way into creating prisons and all that we know, you know, the last 120 something years about prisons.
But what did you learn about the limitations of attempting to reform the criminal legal system?
And we can be very frustrating and we've been for the last 50, 60 years.
>> In a time of increasing punishment harshness and punitive nus and lack of compassion for people who have done harm.
And yet there's always been a counter revolution are kind movement against that.
So.
I think we have we can't give up hope that things can get better and small ways in different parts of the country.
They are better than they used to be.
doesn't mean that we don't have a lot of work to do.
One of the challenges that a small decision can be made.
Now.
Let's say that make mandatory minimums.
And then 50 years from now, the people incarcerated because of decision.
So you might fix that policy at some point.
what about all the people already got locked up?
So it just takes generational thinking it takes visionary, thinking to recognize that we have to make lots of small choices.
Now.
Put ourselves in a better direction and that might pay off.
All gone.
>> And for 200 years, people have argued about the root of crime as well.
Going through the records and interviews.
What did you glean from exploring that question?
That was new to you.
I was new to me.
A lot of this history was new to me.
>> And I think even even though I've studied American history in many different ways for my whole career.
This question of the root cause of crime.
I think it's interesting that really hasn't been much of a debate.
About the fact that poverty.
Can lead to crime.
And trauma can lead to crime and just deprivation can lead to crime.
And so this is not a surprise.
This is not something we need to learn.
we need to think about is what are we going to do about that?
We've sort basically for the most of our history, just felt like, well, we can do the person who committed the crime tale that and not really focus on what happened before.
That put the person on this path.
And I hope I found the help shed some light on why that way of thinking is perhaps something we should be, you evaluating.
>> You also focus on storytelling around Crime and Punishment.
One story in particular, John Henry, he was made to work in a convict leasing prison program.
He dies and he becomes a folk hero, quote, dined with a hammer in his hand.
But to the shock of some people turns out that his story is much more complicated than that.
we learn so much making this film and this one was a real stunner for me.
I was I personally I grew up with John Henry and the legend.
The folk songs.
>> And inspiring story of a man who was so strong superhuman strength.
You can be the machine and it worked himself to death because he beat this machine and then he just died we found out that there was a real person named John Henry, who was a victim of convict leasing, which in the Jim Crow South.
But you could be arrested and tried for petty crime and then set to present and then you'll be hired out.
To a private contractor business.
They can bring you out of the president anywhere they wanted and force you to work.
And this happened to thousands and thousands of people and the conditions were horrific and mortality rates for astronomical.
And we were able to trace not we during was able to trace what happened to this actual real person.
John Henry, who's one of probably 100 out of 200 people in this one work site who died.
And, you know, the people who survived it.
Try to make a heroic story out of it to not focus on the deprivation and the degradation and you know, tell an inspiring story.
it got turned into this beautiful math.
We feel it's important to know the truth about what actually happened to him.
So understand our own history better.
You talked to the family members of Polly Klass.
She was kidnapped and murdered in the 90's infamous 3 strikes laws which mandates severe prison terms.
>> We're past in her name, but her 2 sisters were actually regretful of this.
Why was that?
Yeah, a really it's never a beautiful and inspiring story.
This was one of the most high-profile crimes of the 1990's.
Galvanize the tough on crime agenda and gave reason to pass strikes laws because the man committed the crime was out on parole in California.
So the argument was.
If we had a 3 strikes law, this guy would have been on the streets and, you know, that is technically true, but a lot soft it so much time to so many people who ended up going locked up for life sentences for very small crimes and the family.
The 2 sisters of this little girl who was killed have started in the last 5, 6 years speaking publicly about how they as a family and they themselves.
feel a lot of guilt and shame about Stephan.
Other course.
They weren't responsible for it.
And they understand that this type of approach to addressing crime and harm does more damage than it helps make society.
just and fair and safe.
And so I find their story inspiring because they could just be quietly sitting on the sidelines.
Len, what do you hope people take away from the series?
Yeah.
I really hope that by learning this history can all engaging deeper conversations about how we do justice in this country.
What is the purpose of punishment?
Our presidents actually making us safer.
How do we get to a place where we have accountability and public safety and justice?
And that our system that's that our criminal justice system is not only there to punish people.
Which is what it basically is right now.
looking forward to seeing the series win over.
Thank you so much for joining
Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee on Inflation, Unemployment
Video has Closed Captions
Estimates put the annual inflation rate at 4% — double the Fed's target. (8m 33s)
New Investigation Explores What's Behind Chicago's $55 Billion in Debt
Video has Closed Captions
A joint investigation from WTTW News and ProPublica shows the impact of Chicago's crushing debt. (3m 37s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.


New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
Chicago Tonight is a local public television program presented by WTTW
WTTW video streaming support provided by members and sponsors.

