Made Here
Green River Reservoir
Season 20 Episode 4 | 56m 57sVideo has Closed Captions
The history and future of a pristine natural resource in Vermont.
The Green River Reservoir sits just north of Hyde Park, Vermont. It’s a pristine body of water, full of wildlife and bountiful fishing which attracts thousands of visitors every year. Problems relicensing the dam threatens the park's future.
Made Here is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by the John M. Bissell Foundation, Inc. | Learn about the Made Here Fund
Made Here
Green River Reservoir
Season 20 Episode 4 | 56m 57sVideo has Closed Captions
The Green River Reservoir sits just north of Hyde Park, Vermont. It’s a pristine body of water, full of wildlife and bountiful fishing which attracts thousands of visitors every year. Problems relicensing the dam threatens the park's future.
How to Watch Made Here
Made Here is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipPart of These Collections
Sports & Recreation
Enjoy films focused on sports and recreation in the great outdoors.
View CollectionProviding Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship-Hi, I'm -Eric Ford for Made Here.
-The newest film -from Vermonter, Ian Sweet, -focuses on the green River -reservoir, -which sits just north of Hyde -Park in Lamoille County.
-It's a pristine -body of water, -full of wildlife -and Bountiful fishing, -which attracts thousands -of visitors every year.
-Ian's film -looks at the history -of this natural resource -and its future -in light of climate change, -economics and land use.
-You can watch green River -reservoir and other great -made here films -streaming on our website -and through the PBS app.
-Enjoy the film -and thanks for watching.
-(Singing): When the -noise of the world -is too much to bear.
-There's a place you can go.
-With clean air.
-It's the wind in the pines.
-And the song of the moon.
-Calling for you to.
-And calling for you.
-Oh, green river, -seat of our soul.
-Oh, green River, -won't you take us home?
-Dip your all in.
-Wanna -watch the rivers flow.
-Cast your light.
-Sons and daughters.
-In the evening glow.
-And the birds mark -the seasons.
-And the stars shine above.
-Calling for you.
-Calling for you.
-Oh, green River.
-See the our on -O green River.
-Won't you take us home?
-May it stay this way forever.
-May it shine.
-May stay this way forever.
-Yours and mine.
-May it stay this way forever.
-May shine.
-May stay this way forever.
-Yours and mine.
-It's quite -an interesting long history.
-They built the dam for.
-For multiple purposes.
-As far back, -I think the earliest one -I saw was 1917.
-People had to recognize -the importance of the area -and were investing in it -by buying up -the land before anything -was actually in process.
-So then what happened -was, Green Mountain Power, -who actually then, you know, -eventually took over central -Vermont public service.
-But they consolidated -the land and, they -then decided to move ahead -with this, -this construction of this dam -and the two purposes were -they were thinking about long -term power production.
-And then the other thing was, -this was flood control, -but it was much later -that then they finally put in -they had plans for actually -two electrical production -facilities -on the green River.
-One of them -which they built initially -with a -1.8, megawatt generator.
-And then they were going -to put a bigger, facility -slightly down the, -down the stream, -a mile and a half.
-There used to be a little, -hamlet called, Garfield.
-And, now it's mostly -all gone, -and they never built that, -and that was going -to be twice as big.
-But eventually -Marston Water and Light -took control of the, -property, -and they ran -that successfully -for quite a while -doing logging.
-And, letting anybody use it.
-You know, it was open for -anybody to come and, camp.
-And it got to be -fairly popular after a while.
-So the people that were -using it like Bill Bartlett -and others, decided that, -you know, this was a great -asset that we ought to -spend some time and -get the -state to be interested in it -and set it up as a park -so we wouldn't have it -trashed -by people of industrial -camping everywhere.
-My husband -and I, Bill Bartlett, -and we discovered -green River reservoir, -or I'd say in 74, -and there was no one there.
-it was a totally deserted -sort of a place.
-We discovered -a couple of the islands -and we'd go up and we'd -then take our basset hound -and, pile him into the canoe, -and we'd go out to one -of the islands and we'd camp.
-So it was really from -from that time forward -that we actively used -the reservoir.
-And it was from that long -involvement -that the Friends of Green -Reservoir developed.
-Actually, when I -moved to Vermont, I had -already had about 9000 -miles of open boat paddling.
-The green River -reservoir was much more wild -wilderness -like than it is now.
-Water and light put a barrier -across the entrance -to the water.
-The reservoir there, -with multiple layers of heavy -duty cable that was attached -to the utility pole.
-And that work -because nobody -is going to want to sort -through that -with their chainsaw.
-The leadership of Morse -will water like to put it, -put a gate -at the top of the ramp -where the kiosk is now.
-so it meant that -motorboats were not allowed.
-However, it came about, -it was truly one of the most -extraordinary gifts -that Morse for water -allied leadership gave, -almost maybe unknowingly, -to the community -and to northern Vermont -and to all of us who, -really value, -paddling, -bodies of water that are -largely undeveloped -and without any motorboat.
-So I had already been here, -for 20 years, -paddling on the reservoir.
-I had also, at that point -in 1990, -I had known Bill for about an -15, 18 years.
-So we met in 72, 73.
-And when we began noticing -that, -the use of the green River -reservoir -was ramping up, -and at that time, -Mooresville water -lights approach -to management was hands off -at the gate.
-and no motorboats.
-And that was good enough.
-It really was good enough.
-So users were unregulated -and we noticed that -campsites -were popping up everywhere -and people were, -going to the bathroom in the -woods, leaving toilet paper -and their human tours because -there were no outhouses.
-There was nothing there.
-Bill Bartlett's life -work around water quality, -the reason that the quality -of water is what it is -in the state of Vermont -is largely because of Bill, -who was was a fierce advocate -for keeping Vermont's -waters clean.
-I personally mapped -with a small group of people -every single campsite, -and we located, campsites -and we -we noted the size -of each of these campsites.
-So we measured -the perimeter of the impact.
-So we just as a group -started going up in the fall, -and then we'd -go back up in the spring -just to clean things up -and decided, well, -we're doing this -and we'll call ourselves -the friends in Green River.
-And, -became more actively involved -with with working -with Morrisville Water -and Light, -letting them know, you know, -we were cleaning it up -and doing that.
-And that was fine.
-And, Forest and Parks -and the Agency -of Natural Resources -had been interested -in buying green River -reservoir for years.
-But it had never in terms -of everything they do, -it was way down the list.
-So it didn't, you know, -and Forest and Parks, -to this day, is -still terribly underfunded.
-And they have issues -trying to trying to take care -of what they already have -as parks.
-So it wasn't there -all.
Let's buy it.
-Let's buy it.
-But, I then began -I was into my political -career in the Senate -and, was also on -the Appropriations Committee -and for many years -chairs of appropriations.
-So I said, well, let's -see if we can bump this -a little further up -the further up the list.
And, -the, -had some -conversations with the state -and they were -certainly interested in it -at that time, not necessarily -having it be a state park, -but at least getting it, -getting it purchased.
-So, as many things happen -in small communities, -I had a conversation -with the -then chair of Morrisville -Water and Light -and said, you know, I think, -I think we can come up -with a package deal and -we can and we could buy this.
-Would you are -you guys really interested?
-Would you like to do it?
-And he said, -let me talk to his board.
-So we talked to his board -and they said, yes.
-And, Natural Resources -Council, we -they had the money and -and so we, -we sort of quietly -just got the deal done -and it got purchased.
-Senator Leahy was always -a tremendous champion -of making sure -that that organizations -that particularly helped -with conservation -in this state, had access -and would get federal -funds in to them -so that the money -so that the money was there -and, and there's -and there's always Senator -Leahy came through and, and, -helped them -come up -with the missing dollars -so that they were able to -have the cash to do the deal.
-We are a conservation -organization existing really -just to -preserve the wilderness -like qualities of green River -reservoir, which we all feel -very passionately about.
-We're of all people involved -in paddling -and camping there.
-We were formed -when that land was sold, -was coming up for sale, -and we very much -wanted to be a state park.
-So we did absolutely -everything we could do to -to help -the other conservation -organizations that were -pulling it together.
-Since then, our primary goal -has been to do -whatever we can -to help preserve the the, -the reservoir -and support the state park -in ways that we can.
And.
-There's a local gem, -and state resources -just really aren't -sufficient to manage it -and take care of it properly.
-So local folks and users of -it step up to the plate.
-And and again, for the -for the we already had the, -the organization, -the Friends of Green River.
-but to be able to -raise money, -to help, pay -for some of the initial staff -to help pay -for building the buildings, -just all those sorts -of things that, that they've -been able -to turn green River into a, -into a lovely, state park.
-The Agency -of Natural Resources -includes three departments.
-The Department -of Environmental -Conservation, -where most of our regulatory -programs are housed.
-the department of Fish -and Wildlife -and then the Department of -Forest, Parks and Recreation.
-and within FPR, -we have the staff responsible -for managing, Vermont's -55 staff, state parks -in the northeast.
-Here I -have 18 staff locations.
-and that's I'm primarily -responsible for the parks -from the summit of Mansfield -East and Berry North.
-Greener reservoir -fits into the northeast, -state parks -and into the state -park system as a whole.
-it's one of our, you know, -one of the gems of the state -park system.
-It's, it's it's a very -unique and special location.
-It's quite different -than most of our other more -developed campgrounds.
-what we have here -is a focus on maintaining -the wilderness -like characteristics -of the location, -and providing opportunities -for dispersed -outdoor recreation.
-As we see -about 18,000 visitors, -to the green River Reservoir -State Park each year, -both in as campers -as well as day users.
-it is a well, beloved fishery -and just this, incredible, -surface water body with out -motorized craft.
-And it's one of the few -in the state.
-And so, -no, it is at the top -of many paddlers lists -of favorite places to go.
-So the -friends became, an advisor -to the state -on operations, -on facilities, programing.
-And we help support the state -with money with master -planning at no charge.
-We became involved -with some of the early design -of the moldering -of the composting toilets.
-We designed, and helped -pay for the contact station.
-I designed, the middle -parking lot and the boardwalk -that is the accessible trail, -the kiosk.
-Equally important, -we became, helped -with the protection of -the view shed within the land -that can be seen -from the waters -of the reservoir -during the summer months.
-As we became an instrument -of support for the state.
-And in return, the state.
-agreed to meet with us twice -a year to really promote -the educational opportunities -that the park staff have -with virtually -every single visitor about -why it's so important -to not have motorboats, -or to be quiet -when you're paddling, -or to take care -of your campsite -to clean up, -to use the moldering toilets, -to value the place that bill -and many of us had known -from the early 70s -through the 90s -when there was such a -huge perforation, unregulated -proliferation of use.
-I make -sure that all -the daily chores get done.
-reservations.
-I make sure -all the financial, -task we have to do -stay up to date -and just, you know, manage -the general staff here.
-It's one of the few parks -where -all of the sites are remote.
-You can only reach in -by canoe or kayak or paddle -board.
-These days.
-We have a lot of others.
-First and foremost, -it's like keeping -keeping the attendant safe -and well -prepared for the day.
-And, you know, really trying -to pass on some knowledge -and hopefully that trickles -down into the guests and, -just keep everything -going in the background -as best as I can -and hope everyone, -you know, the guests and, -the staff -included, -are having a good summer.
-We check every campsite, -we make sure there's -no what we call micro trash.
-You know, bottle caps -or pull tabs.
-we clean the fire pit.
-we check the composting -toilet to make sure that -it's, you -know, -everything's clean up there.
-we keep buckets of sawdust -or wood shavings -at each site.
-Yeah, people want that.
-They want they want to go out -and they want to.
-They want to have, -a wilderness like experience.
-They they they -some people want that quiet.
-They want the solitude.
-They want to listen -to the loons, -in a more -developed campground.
-Sometimes -you have a little more noise.
-well, all over campgrounds, -there's typically -not a whole lot of issues, -with people, -but it's more of a family -scene, and they'll be kids -riding bikes and people -having fun and barbecues -and stuff like that.
-But this place is for -the people -that want to go out -and really experience, -being in a more remote area.
-The green River Reservoir -State Park is absolutely, -one of the gems for loon -habitat.
-partly -because of all the bays -and islands, loons like -to have their own little 70 -to 100 acre zones, -for territories.
-And it's one of the places -we've had a long term pair -since 1978.
-The population in the state -bottomed out in 1983 -with 12 pairs.
-One of those -was the northwest -site at green River.
-They're pretty steady -throughout the 80s and 90s.
-And then in, early 2000, -a second pair -formed on green River.
-And then in -just after 2010, two -more pairs have now formed.
-Really, only two of the pairs -are productive -from being very successful -on their island sites, -producing chicks -consistently.
-The other two still haven't -quite figured it out.
-Partly the habitat's -not quite so good.
-And also competition.
-is starting to play a factor -with the loons -sort of intermingling -with each other, -and that can interfere -with nesting.
-whether they nest or not.
-It can interfere -with nest success.
-It can interfere with chicks -survivorship as well.
-but overall, those -especially the -the access cove -in the northwest cove -now are consistently -producing chicks.
-Maybe not every year, but, -quite often.
-And it's actually become a -kind of a little central hub -where you get non breeders -flying in, hanging out.
-and so in the middle -of the reservoir, -you'll often -see a group of 8 to 10 loons, -just kind of -checking each other out.
-Some of those are the pairs -part of the pairs -from the reservoir itself -coming out and joining -that group.
-Others are flying in -from nearby ponds.
-and, you know, living -that's part of loon -life is always -sort of assessing -territories, -assessing each other, -getting to know -the neighbors.
-so it's it's -just been a super great spot, -to it's all natural nesting.
-We do put nest warning -signs out, -because of all the canoeing -kayak traffic and just -essentially asking boaters -to stay 50 to 100ft away -from the nest sites.
-And that just gives them, -a little breathing room -during their most vulnerable -time.
-When they're out -in the water, -they can just kind of swim -around and, -you know, there's -nothing really -that's going to bother them -too much.
-They kind of know -what's a threat -and what's not a threat.
-But when they're on the nest, -they can't fly from land.
-and so to feel safe, -they often -would get into the water if, -if something of threat came -nearby, -whether it's a person -or whether it's an eagle, -they might, might get off.
-So eagles are going to be -an interesting factor -over the next decade.
-See how they influence, -nest success and chick -survivorship.
-but it's also -one of the places -where loons have become -very habituated -to kayak and canoe traffic.
-So oftentimes -they'll bring in their chicks -right up near people -and they can just -get a really amazing look.
-That from here.
-Yeah.
Cool.
-So we are on Zach Woods -Pond right now.
-And we've been watching -two chicks.
-And now that's the second -adult coming in.
-it's been on its own over -in that corner.
-So really, -another little special gem -which is a part of the green -River State Park.
-We used to think that loons -made it for life.
-that was back in the 1980s -when before we learned -or before we figured out -a way to, tag loons, -but color -bands on their legs.
-but since that time, -in the late 80s, early 90s, -some techniques came along -to be able -to successfully capture loons -and put color bands, -and we could look -at return rates.
-And through that work, -we've discovered -that about 80% of the time -it's the same male and female -returning every year.
-but about 20% of the time -there's a -switch in the mates.
-Some of that's mortality.
-some of it -a loon might move to a -different part of a lake -for unknown reasons.
-Or another lake nearby.
-and then the other one -is the switches and mates, -where you actually get -a territorial challenge.
-And I was talking about -those groups of loons -out on green River.
-Well, that's -part of what's happening -is they're assessing -each other.
-And is that pair prone -to a takeover, -or is that pair really strong -and leave them alone.
-And so they're communicating -that all the time, both -vocally, through the calls, -through the male yodel.
-but also visually, -through little interactions -and head bobbing and, -and diving and posturing.
-That's all sort of saying, -you know, -who's who's strong, -who's not.
-and if, if you're if those -intruder loons, extra loons -might be game for a takeover -and you'll actually see -chases and challenges -and maybe a fight, -but oftentimes -it never gets to that level.
-It's it's more -of a communication thing.
-so those, those, those non -breeders are always kind of -again assessing territories.
-And they'll -when a chick returns -to the area, -they usually spend 3 -or 4 years on the ocean.
-They'll come back -to their natal lake area, -but not often, -maybe not to the same lake.
-but then they'll spend three -or 4 or 5 years -investigating the region -before they actually find -a spot to nest.
-They don't nest on average -until they're 6 -or 7, eight years of age.
-and a loon -might -get kicked off a territory -and then have to look -for a new one -so that there's just all -of this interaction going on.
-And which is a kind of a neat -thing about loons, is -we can watch that, and be -part of that all the time.
-It's easier -if it's their mark loons -and you know who's who.
-But we don't.
-We only have a few birds -marked in Vermont.
-So when a bird finally finds -a spot in a territory, -they'll made up the.
-The average -marriage of a loon -is about 4 or 5 years -before there's a switch -in one of those mates.
-sometimes -there's a switch right away -because the pair's weak -or something's wrong or, -or there's -a really strong intruder.
-But other pairs might last -for 1015.
-and in one case, out -in Michigan, -there's a pair that's -been together over 20 years.
-So why do -loons only lay 1 or 2 eggs?
-compared to a mere gander -might have, you know, -seven or more eggs.
-It's a different life -strategy.
-loons are, super involved -in the parental care -and don't care -for their chicks -right up into October, -even November in some cases.
-And when you have that length -of commitment to the chicks, -they tend to only have 1 -or 2 young eagles -or that way as well.
-and, but the survivorship -is really high relative -to the number of eggs -that have been laid.
-So in Vermont -we've been seeing about 70%, -even 75% chick -survivorship rate.
-whereas survivorship -of the type of bird -that lays -ten eggs is really low, -they're hoping to at least -get one or 2 or 3 of those -to survive.
-So it's a different strategy.
-Where do you where do you -invest for loons?
-They invested in parenting -both male and female.
-Share -in every activity equally.
-And that that includes nest -incubation.
-It also includes -feeding the young kid.
-It's defending the young -and caring for the young.
-both the male -and female are involved -in every process equally.
-it's just, you know, -really neat to see, -but kind of both the male -and female out there, -you can't tell the male -and female apart, -visually, except that males -are bigger than the female.
-loons were adapted -to be swimmers and fliers, -but they're not land -creatures.
-Their legs are in the back -of their body, -so they can actually -they can't actually -walk on land.
-They can kind of shuffle -on their bellies.
-They can raise up -to turn an egg, -and then they flat -right back down again.
-And that's one reason why -they nest one, two, -maybe three feet -from the shoreline.
-and so they could easily, -like, pop into the water -when a threat comes near, -whether that's a raccoon -or a fox or whether -that's a human in a boat, -they feel safe in the water.
-They do not feel safe -on the land.
-if you come across a nest -and it's not marked, we don't -put signs around all nests.
-that loon might hunker down -and put its head out -and sort of lie -in a prone position.
-it's sort of -getting out of bird shape.
-So a predator is often -focused in on the bird -shape of the head, -or it's focused on movement, -whereas if a loon lays -real flat, -it becomes a stick.
-and that zebra -coloring, the black and white -you mix in a few grasses, -it can be really hard -to see a loon -sitting on a nest -in that position.
-So loons in Vermont -are doing really well.
-A conservation standpoint -is to, to maintain that.
-and so part of our effort -is to work with, volunteers.
-So the folks at the state -park, -the Friends of Green River -reservoir, -and they become kind of -the eyes and ears of, of -watching the parrot and, -and educating other people.
-I'm kind of a coordinator -of all of that.
-And loons are such, an icon.
-When I got my -first Pentax camera in 1970, -and I've been doing -photography ever since, loon -monitoring, -I began that in 2010 -because that forces me to -get out early in the morning, -when the waters -are relatively calm -and when there's better -chances of seeing wildlife.
-so I'm always carrying -this camera and -and a telephoto lens with me.
-I put it in this water -waterproof case here -until I get into the -my kayak.
-If I can get out there -when the chicks are just -newly born, that's when -I get the greatest pictures.
-And my knowing when they nest -because -I report that to Eric Hansen.
-And then he lets water -and light know -and they try -to maintain the water level.
-So by that the gestation -period is about 28 days.
-So then I try to time -expected hatch -to some of my trips, -and if I'm lucky, I get there -just on the day -they've hatched -or the day after that -and get some good pictures.
-All wildlife is attracted -to me from the insects -all the -way up to the deer and moose.
-numerous kinds of -ducks, including wood ducks, -which -I think are really beautiful.
-the dancers -with their babies, -there's always geese, -an occasional hawk.
-Sometimes in the fall -or spring, -I'll get a migratory bird -that just happens to be -there, like Bonaparte's Gull.
-And I got a great picture -of a couple of years ago -in flight, flying -right toward me -in the early spring.
-There'll be a lot of, trees, -swallows flying around.
-this time of year, -you'll see -a lot of phoebes -swooping down -over the water -to get insects in the back up -to, overhang -or something like that.
-There's -always something of interest.
-Well, I've got lots, lots -of great shots of beavers.
-in all stages, -including just the tail -going up in the air.
-I don't think they're -a great threat to the loons, -but snapping turtles might be -a little larger threat.
-But the biggest threat -is probably the bald eagle.
-few years ago, somebody, -actually one of the kayakers -actually observed -the bald eagle taking one of -the chicks out of the water.
-What's so special about -it is being quiet waters.
-No motorboats around.
-You can swim way out and -not have to worry about it.
-And when I'm out there -doing my photography, -I can get up.
-I can cruise -quietly into those areas -where I traditionally see -wildlife -and not scare them and -be able to photograph them.
-The highlight -is probably that picture -of the loon with two chicks -on the back side -I got in 2015.
-That's the only one -I've gotten with two chicks.
-It's quite rare.
-!Most often it'll be one on the b -So this -is, the Vermont Forest Bird -Monitoring Project.
-We started this in 1989, -I think with six study -sites around the state, -and we now have about 30 -study sites around the state.
-And these are sites -that are monitored -primarily by, by volunteers.
-And they consist of five -point counts separated, -by about 200m each.
-And the observers visit -these sites every year -during the height of the -breeding season and June -and, survey birds for -ten minutes at each point.
-And, all of our study -sites are located -in interior forest, -so they're away from, -edges, impacts -of development and roadsides -and things that can affect, -bird populations.
-so these are interior forest -sites, and most of them, -almost all of them are sites -that are free from any -kind of forest management.
-So there's -no timber harvest or -or any kind of forest -management going on.
-So that eliminates one, -one variable that can affect -bird populations -and sort of confound the, -determination of long term -trends and what's, -what's going on -with forest birds.
-And that's the whole reason -why we -we started it to get, -sort of, -to, to monitor -bird populations over time -and track population -trends to see how these -birds are doing -there.
-There are a few species -that that are declining -and continue -to decline and have, -you know, have been declining -since the beginning, Canada -warbler being one of them.
-We have documented, -decline in the overall -abundance of the forest birds -that we've been studying -for these 30 plus years.
-But there are certainly, -number of species -that stay here -for the winter.
-Woodpeckers and.
-chickadees.
-blue jays, -you know, a number.
-And there's also -the species who are short -distance migrants -who may only go -to the Mid-Atlantic states, -and then we may get birds -from Canada -who just come to this area -for the winter.
-so we might the Blue Jays -we see here in the summer -might not be the Blue -Jays we're seeing here -in the winter.
-When we started the project.
-There's no end date.
-It's just long term -monitoring.
-And, the hope is -it will continue for the long -for the long term.
-This site is, -as Steve mentioned, -part of the forest bird -monitoring program at BCE.
-and this summer -it's been one of the sites, -along with other forest bird -monitoring program sites -across northern and north -central Vermont, -that we've been serving -as part of this larger -maple study, of which -BCE Audubon Vermont -and a team -at the University of Vermont -are part.
-this summer has really been -to look at -untapped, -unmanaged forest stands, -to compare with previously -surveyed sites -that were active -sugar bushes in 2020, -2021 and 2022.
-so those years we were doing -all the same surveys, -all the same protocols, -looking at birds, looking -at vegetation and looking at -our three pods, -which are, insects -and a number of other -basically creepy crawly -groups that are bird food.
-in.
Yeah.
-So we're looking at those -in sugar bushes -and now those in unmanaged -northern hardwood forest -stands, basically maple.
-Not a shocker -for any Vermonters -watching is a big industry -here in Vermont.
-it's expanding to the point -where we're getting wall -Street -investment in sugaring.
-and so I think there's a -there's a lot of concern, -both amongst the public, -but also at the sort -of regulatory -level of what impacts -may this have as we're -converting forests -that are either unmanaged -or managed for wildlife -goals, -or are managed for timber -and other wood products -production.
-What is the impact -if we're we're converting -those stands -over to Sugarbush?
-if there are any -I think foresters -have a, practitioner's -understanding -of the realities -of what that means.
-But the way -that science works -is that if no one's tested it -or looked at it, through, -scientific approach, -and it's not published -in the peer -reviewed literature, science -doesn't know it to be true.
-And so basically, this study -with Audubon Vermont -and BCE is looking to see, -what are the impacts -that maple sugaring -has on our forests -and our forest birds?
-And, -how effective is Audubon -Vermont's bird friendly -maple program at potentially -mitigating some of those, -what we don't -know are negative impacts, -but could be negative -impacts on birds.
-I moved here to, -northern Vermont, -51 years ago, and I was hired -on as a game warden.
-And after a year of training, -I was assigned -to the Moyle County -as a, the field warden here.
-And Revd.
-Franklin Hooper was the, -the warden that had been here -for since 1933.
-And I was going to -take over for him -because he was about -to retire at age 70.
-One of the first places -that Red took -me was up on green River -reservoir.
-And, I saw the first loons, -and I just fell in love with -that with that reservoir.
-So I've been, been involved -with the reservoir -ever since.
-One of my favorite places -to patrol.
-I'd go up there and canoe, -and I'd check fishermen -and talk to campers -and, just really enjoy -that whole that whole area.
-When I first got here, -it was primarily -pickerel and perch.
-there was the biologists -when they did a survey -a few years after I got here, -also found -that there was a good -population of suckers, -but people rarely catch them, -and they're down pretty deep.
-so folks would troll -for pickerel, -and, I'd fish for perch.
-but there was no bass -at that time.
-And, I had -we had a lot of back -and forth with a biologist -and decided that, -it would be great -to introduce bass -into green River reservoir.
-So we, the first year -and this would have -been, let's say mid -70s, something around there.
-they netted -some bass over Hardwick Way, -Nelson Pond, -Mack Pond, that area, -and brought them over -and I think was like -250 bass, different sizes -and released them.
-And then the next year -they got a bunch of fry, -I think, from New York State -and, put them in and that -fishery just took off.
-It was really a tremendous -bass fishery.
-people started to learn -about it and were coming.
-evening fishing -with topwater laws was great.
-fly fishing for them, -particularly an early -season was was really fun -and, it was very popular, -fishing there.
-So I had -I had lots of folks -to talk to -when I'd go up there -on patrol.
-They were using it then -more as a, -a storage facility for water.
-And when they wanted -to, needed more water -at their facilities -downstream -on the Illinois River, -they would release.
-And sometimes that would be -a significant amount of -water going downstream -or on -Garfield Road that -the green River runs under.
-And when we only open -one tube, -the paddlers feel like -it's not quite enough water.
-If we open two, we threaten -to wipe that culvert out.
-We are totally open -to working on on releases -as is currently contained -in the water quality permit.
-you know, recreational use -is a good and viable thing.
-We want to have all partners -be good partners.
-We want everyone to be able -to move forward together.
-So the green River outside -of Morrisville, Vermont, -it's about three miles -of whitewater that we kind -of pay attention to.
-And it goes down -into the Lamoille.
-right -where crosses under route 15.
-it's about -class three four and -a couple class five rapids.
-And it sits in -a pristine, remote area that, -is pretty, -pretty unique for Vermont.
-I've been paddling -the green River, somewhere -along 2012, 2013, -a couple of years after -they did the, flow study -and they figured out -that they could get -dam releases on it.
-and then we would kind of go -up, we'd get five, -six days a year -where they'd let us know that -we can go paddle it.
And, -typically we'd -have a pretty good turnout.
-Sometimes, you know, -you get 15 boaters, -sometimes you get 40.
-if you can know about it -in advance -and it's the right weekend, -you can get a pretty good -turnout.
-So usually, you know, -there has to be enough water -in the reservoir.
-they are either -doing a fall draw down -and trying to bring -the reservoir height -to a certain -height, before winter.
-same thing could be in -the spring after, you know, -all the snow is melted -and filled the reservoir.
-or we get a big rainstorm -and they know -they need to dump water -to keep it -at a certain height.
-I know -they're pretty particular -about the loon -nesting up there.
-There's a lot of that -going on, -and they like to have -a certain water level.
-And what's really special -about the green is -say we get a big storm -on Tuesday, -and Vermont kayaking is like, -you better go kayaking now -because it just rained -and you have a day or two.
-But with the green, -that rain -could have fallen on Tuesday -and they could let us know, -hey, we need to dump water -this Saturday and Sunday -we'll do a release and -having that ability -to have it planned -makes it a very unique -and special thing.
-Kayaking is class -one through five, class -one kind of moving water, -a little bit of repose.
-Two is a little harder, three -some action, some some, -but still relatively -straightforward.
-Class four -gets a little -more challenging, -and you have to be able -to pick your path.
-Maybe -you should have a whitewater, -you know, roll -or you can flip back up.
-And class five is is pretty -full on waterfalls and, -not much room for error.
-So the green has it's -a majority class for run.
-And there's three drops -that class five.
-And you can walk around them -if you want.
-or you can kayak them.
-And so the class five drops -I'll start there -because it's kind of visually -the easiest thing to see.
-you're -looking at the first run, -the first one -we call moonshine, -and it's a ten foot -waterfall, and it lands, -in a small eddy of calm -water, if there is any.
-And then it's very involved.
-Once you go from there.
-So it takes a lot of skill, -you know, to be online, -hit the drop -and then paddle away.
-and there's a lot of, -you know, -there's a moderate -amount of consequence -if you don't, you know, are -are there -things that could create -a class five rapid or hazard, -such as undercuts, -strainers and siphons.
-So where water -might go through.
-But a person couldn't, -if that makes sense.
-there's a drop -in the middle of the run -called young Buck that -gets run, -but more often gets portage -because there's -strainers and and siphons.
-but it's an easy, just -kind of get out your boat, -walk around, look at that, -and then you get on -with the rest of the run.
-and then class four -is we're in our boats more -just kind of, -you know, we can probably -look over the horizon line -and see that it's okay.
-and it's, it's moving -a little bit slower paced.
-and the lines aren't -as hard to hit.
-So think of it, you know, -you go to a ski resort -and you see a blue square, -a diamond -and a double black diamond.
-once you've done it -a few times, it's pretty easy -to see standing at the top -what you're getting yourself -into.
-The agency of natural -resources, -has an important role -in the relicensing of dams.
-We are specifically -responsible, for reviewing, -hydropower, relicensing, -initiatives to ensure -that they comply -with the state's -water quality standards, -which is, a set of chemical -and physical, -requirements -that all projects -in the state -need to comply with.
-We license -hydropower facilities -generally for 30 to 50 year -terms.
-that's different than almost -any other permit -issued by this agency, -which generally -has a five year term.
-so Morrisville -Water and Light -is operating under a license, -that was issued -shortly after the the initial -Clean Water Act -in certainly our knowledge.
-and goals for environmental -protection have continued -to evolve, -over the past decades.
-And that's also reflected -in the the 401 certification -we issued for this project.
-and I think, you know, -it looks new.
-And so Morrisville has had -more questions maybe than, -we would expect -in a traditional regulatory -process -that occurred on -a five year interval.
-So these are complicated -undertakings.
-they have several parties, -the Morrisville -Water and Light, -the agency, as well as Ferc.
-there are appeals -processes that Morrisville -has avail themselves -of at different points -in the process, -that have certainly slowed -things down.
-and these are big, -complicated undertakings.
-The Federal Energy -Regulatory Committee, -which ultimately license -the dam, tells the applicant -in this case, Morrisville -Water and Light, -that they need to check -with the state agency, -in this case from an agency -of natural resources to make -sure that as they issue -this new 40 year license, -the conditions of the license -are appropriate -to protect water quality -and uphold the state's -water quality standards.
-And that includes issues like -the health of the stream.
-As far as its ability -to provide habitat -for fish -and other aquatic animals.
-In this case, -when the agency -of natural resources -looked at the downstream -condition of the dam -and the condition of -the habitat in the reservoir, -as the dam has been -operating -under the old license -for the last 40 years, -the scientists at the state -agency determined -that the level of flows -in the river below -the dam were not appropriate -for supporting healthy -communities of fish, healthy -reproduction of fish, -as well as the life -cycle of the bugs.
-And so the agency had -determined that there needed -to be some adjustments -in the flow regime -below the dam.
-The agency also looked at -the health of aquatic plants -and animals such -as dragonflies and loons, -and how they were affected -by the winter -drawdown of the reservoir, -the amount of water -that the utility -was taking out of the dam -during winter time in order -to generate hydroelectricity, -and after scientific study, -not just by the agency, -but the agency looked -at reports that were produced -by Morrisville and Water -and Light's own scientists, -and determined that -both the amount of drawdown -that was occurring in -the reservoir was too much -to protect the aquatic life -forms in the reservoir.
-And also, -that the amount of flows -that were being released, -from the dam -and the, the timing -and types of those flows, -were not appropriate -to maintain -healthy levels of fish -and other aquatic animals, -as is required by state -water quality standards.
-Trout unlimited, -nationally as an organization -is very concerned -with stream passage issues -of which dams or certainly -play a significant role -for Trout Unlimited -to be involved, -as an intervener -on any number of dam -relicensing issues -that may happen in Vermont.
-That certainly is true -for the Lamoille, which is, -cold water fishery.
-you know, the dams -that, Morrisville, operates -are, you know, -are sort of a -classic examples of dams -where Trout Unlimited would, -would want to be involved -with, creating flows -that are conducive -to the habitat -and also to the cold water -fisheries that, -that exist there.
-Well, the green River -is fairly unique.
-It's, -you know, the green River -as it exists below -the dam is, very cold water -fishery.
-The, green River -reservoir is, bottom release -reservoir, -which consistently releases, -very cold water.
-that creates, -a great little fishery -within the green River -itself of brook -trout and brown trout -and some rainbow, -and also as it flows -into the Lamoille, creates, -helps to, -to keep the temperature -moderated, and cooler, down -below where the green River -comes in.
-But because of the, -the damming -of the green River -and the creation -of the reservoir, -it's also created -a really unique, -cold water plume, from from -the dam that exists for, -a good ways -down the Lamoille as well.
-Morrisville, -like most hydro operators, -wanted as close -to a continuation -of the of the license -that they'd had -for the previous 30 years.
-And the state -typically doesn't love -that idea when they think -about the next advancement -in water quality.
-Yeah.
-So the big issue here -has been largely around -what's the level of change, -for water quality.
-and early in the proceeding, -when you look -at the documents, -everything this references -the Clean Water Act demands -as well.
-Congress last reauthorized -the Clean Water Act in 1992.
-I was secretary -from 1998 to 2003.
-So the Clean Water Act -hasn't changed.
-So I know it's -Clean Water Act said then.
-And so I know -what it says now.
-So really -what Vermont was arguing for -was the next increment -under state interest.
-Really the Clean Water Act, -the Clean Water -Act is very vague -and it gives states -a lot of room.
Right.
-So so the water quality -really the sticking point is -you've got a 100ft tall dam, -and both -for flood protection -and to generate power.
-There's always been around a -ten foot drawdown allowed to -for those purposes.
-And for most of the year -that goes to zero -in the new permits.
-which means you can't really -make that hydro station -has a very difficult time -being of any use, -because the way -the electric system works, -most of the cost -for electricity -is bound up -in what we call peaks.
-So there's, you know, 13 -data points a year, -the peak for every month -and the peak for the year.
-And that drives -most of your cost.
-So hydroelectric -is ideally suited -because you can turn it on -when those peaks -are coming lower -you load and lower -everybody's costs -for the whole year.
-Well, -if you can't draw down at all -like zero -for most of the year, -then you're -not going to be able -to do anything with that.
-so it -really -diminishes the value of, -of the hydroelectric plant -when, -when you go to the level, -that that was contemplated, -you know, throughout -that permitting process, -as we've moved through -a number of these -relicensing facilities, -has been to look to dampen -those those high peaks -and those lower bottoms, -to maintain a more -consistent level of water, -in the channel that reflects -what fish -would have ideally seen -under natural conditions, -recognizing -when it rains, flows come up.
-And sometimes in the summer -when it's drought flows -go way down.
-but to stay within -that range, as opposed to -to dramatically exceeding it, -or falling below it, -based on operation, -we can still draw down -the draw do power.
-We don't do it -nearly as much as we used to, -because we know -that our new permits -are going -to be more restrictive.
-So we've been criticized -in the past -for playing the game, -to be able to draw down ten -feet in the winter time, -we draw down like three feet -because we actually think -nobody -should ever want us -to draw down -less than that -in the wintertime, -because with ice buildups -in the, in the spring, -it's quite possible -you could wipe the dam out -if you don't have anything -drawn down.
-it's one of the things -we're talking -with the state about, about -I think they, their current -water quality permit, -limits us -one foot in the winter, -and we actually think -that's dangerous.
-It's one of things we want -analyzed in this study.
-Even right now, -we're within a 10th of a foot -of fall in the new permit.
-It has to be 0.0.
-We're not going to -I don't know how you can -possibly be 0.0.
-We typically are a foot -and a half at most, -and in the wintertime, -a couple feet, -we're nowhere near -the ten feet -that's in our feet.
-Our current permits still -valid from the early 1980s.
-The, study -the guy will be undertaking -for us -is really a comprehensive -engineering investigation -of the green River -dam facility.
-there has been suggestion on -and off by Morrisville Water -and Light -that they have an interest -in the state -taking ownership -of this facility.
-And we need to make sure -we understand -exactly what condition -the dam is in -before being willing -to engage further -in conversations -about potential state -ownership.
-This is a really significant -dam, one of the largest in -the state.
-the ongoing operation and -maintenance of that facility -is likely to require -significant investments.
-And so it's something -we can't enter into lightly.
-When the noise of the world -is too much to bear.
-There's a place you can go -with clean air.
-It's the wind in the pines.
-And the sound of the moon.
-Calling for you to do.
-Calling for you.
-Oh, green river -seed.
So.
-Oh, green River, -won't you take us home?
-Dip your, -in water -and watch the rivers flow.
-Cast your life.
-Sons and daughters -in the evening.
-Flow and the birds -mark the seasons.
-And the stars shine up.
-Upon calling for you -I'm calling for you.
-Oh, green River -seed.
-Our song.
-Oh, green River.
-Won't you take us home?
-May it stay this way forever.
-May it shine.
-May you stay this way -forever.
-Yours and mine -may stay this way forever.
-May shine.
-May stay this way forever.
-Yours and mine.
-You can breathe here.
-Oh, it's a cherished -resource.
-Here's a local gem.
-It's a very unique -and special location.
-It kind of feels like you're -in backwoods Maine, -even though you're about -five minutes from a town.
-So it's pretty.
-It's beautiful.
-It feels wild stuff.
-One of the gems of the state -park system.
-the designation of the park -is wilderness.
-Like, -one of my favorite places -to patrol that reservoir -makes that so unique.
-Just really enjoy -that whole that whole area.
-The green River -Reservoir State Park -is absolutely one of the gems -for loon habitat.
-What's so special about -it is being the quiet waters.
-What we have here -is a focus on maintaining -the wilderness -like characteristics -of the location.
-Well, it's one of the most -beautiful places on earth.
-public, partnering with local -filmmakers to bring you -stories made here.
-For more, -visit Vermont public.org.
Made Here is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by the John M. Bissell Foundation, Inc. | Learn about the Made Here Fund